Re: Punishment - why?

It's a universal law of cause and effect.

"Michael J Davis" <?.?@trustsof.demon.co.uk> wrote in message news:MUb+IfBkej2HFwmb@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
In working on an essay challenging atheistic beliefs, I have come up
with a problem.

What is the role of 'punishment' in human society? It seesm that many of
our ethical norms relate to the idea that those who break ethical codes
(whether children or adults) should be 'punished'.


To avoid argument and confusion in asking this question I deliberately
**EXCLUDE** other reasons for such sanctions - in particular:-

1. Example (i.e. we punish X so that Y & Z are not encouraged to
emulate X)

2. Protection of society - (i.e. We punish so to deter the
'culprit' from doing it again, and so undermine society.)

3. Rehabilitation. (i.e. Punishment as part of a correction
programme.)

That leaves me (I think) with the simple concept that "those who have
done wrong should suffer" per se.

I would expect atheists to see this to be wrong, and so, I guess, would
Christians. So why does it seem to be inbuilt in human nature that
those who 'do wrong' should suffer?

Mike

[The reply-to address is valid for 30 days from this posting]
--
Michael J Davis
http://www.trustsof.demon.co.uk
<><
For this is what the Lord has said to me,
"Go and post a Watchman and let
him report what he sees." Isa 21:6
<><
.

Relevant Pages

  • Punishment - why?
    ... What is the role of 'punishment' in human society? ... Protection of society - (i.e. ... done wrong should suffer" per se. ...
    (uk.religion.christian)
  • Re: OT: Lethal injection was Re: A big unnecessary problem
    ... Grandpa Chuck wrote: ... am not into "punishment". ... who commit violent acts against others. ... wrath of society down upon them and chooses to do it anyway. ...
    (alt.support.diabetes)
  • Re: George Ryan
    ... By making the allegation that other Brethren, who have done their best to render answers lacked the experience, fortitude and education to render good judgments, it seems as though Bro. ... Perhaps part of the problems we face as a society and as a Craft can be attributed to the fact that what was considered as felonious crime and suitable punishment as enumerated in the Commandments is not reflected in the attitudes and standards of this generation. ...
    (soc.org.freemasonry)
  • Re: Asbos on the way out, signals Theresa May
    ...  Almost all laws are made to curtail activities that are ... aid the smooth running of society, ... it to be a punishment, it would still only be challengable if it was also ...
    (uk.legal)
  • Re: Making money from Java
    ... > Because I extended from all other areas of life. ... > get caught AND not get away with some minor punishment". ... and make them worthwhile members of society. ... For a very long time I believed that the majority of drug addicts (and ...
    (comp.lang.cobol)