Re: cooperation amongst chimps
- From: "Lance" <LanceGary@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: 28 Mar 2006 04:12:21 -0800
Paul wrote:
"My room mate at college announced he gave blood so he could get drunk
more easily. Now that's really ticking all the boxes - good guy and
rebel! "
------------
It is standard fare in Phil 101 to argue that all apparently altruistic
acts can be construed as selfish in one way or another. Sometimes this
proceeds by arguing that some people actually enjoy being martyrs, and
hence burning them at the stake validates their sense of worth. Oh
well...
Your example sounds like self-deprecating rhetoric. It is not "good
form" to be seen as a good deed doer, so find a selfish motive to put
forward to keep up appearances. One reason for avoiding appearing too
altruistic is to avoid inducing others to feel obligated. It is
impoloite to force one's own concerns and charities on others - so
construing them as selfish does the job of keeping the others in the
conversation feeling comfortable. Quite unselfish, really...
Paul wrote:
"These are quite individualistic and violent primates. Why not use
bonobos? They have more of a reputation for being kindly and
co-operative. "
--------------
Availability? Expense? The fact that they are endangered? The fact that
they are less of a challenge to induce to be social?
Lance
.
- References:
- cooperation amongst chimps
- From: Lance
- Re: cooperation amongst chimps
- From: Paul
- cooperation amongst chimps
- Prev by Date: Re: Once a man; twice a child!
- Next by Date: Re: Once a man; twice a child!
- Previous by thread: Re: cooperation amongst chimps
- Next by thread: Now it is the Scottish who have low IQs...
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|