A Cautionary Tale - About Backups



We had a discussion in here about backing up / synchronising / mirroring a while back.

My backups are scheduled and I get an email each morning advising me the status. This morning the email said:

[HDD Usage Status]
RAID Array 1 Usage Rate : 648424 kbytes / 243362140 kbytes (Usage Rate 1%)
RAID Array 2 Usage Rate : 665908 kbytes / 243362140 kbytes (Usage Rate 1%)

Whoops!!!

This is my NAS which has 2 RAID 1 arrays of 250 GB each and which should be about 65% full.

I first checked that my main Data drive was OK, it was, and the primary backup, which is a second HD on the main PC, that was OK too.

I then discovered that a small spare PC had been left on, and it also runs a scheduled backup each night. Unfortunately in playing with it I had fiddled with drive letters not realising the backups were scheduled. What it had done was mirrored the 64MB or so on its HD first to RAID Array 1 and then to RAID Array 2, i.e. it had done exactly what it was supposed to, deleted anything from the RAID arrays that was not on its own HD.

There must be a lesson to be learnt, I suppose a backup rather than mirroring the drives would have prevented this happening. I'll have to think it through.

In the meantime I am running the backups from the main PC, which may take a while, to the NAS to get my data back.

I suppose it proves that there's no such thing as too many backups :-)

--
Jeff Gaines - Damerham Hampshire UK
Using XanaNews 1.18.1.3
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Server Advice Wanted.
    ... > RAID 0+1 will be more efficient (stripping and mirroring), ... which is why you see it less than RAID 5. ... > could still restore from backups because it takes day to do so, ... a network backup solution. ...
    (borland.public.delphi.non-technical)
  • Re: Best Practices on Writes
    ... The mirroring (called Life Keeper Data ... writes are done simultaneously to both drives. ... > those writes in cache. ... >>> from last good backups anyway and the cache doesn't even come into play. ...
    (microsoft.public.sqlserver.setup)
  • Re: RAIDING different size drives
    ... applies to pretend hardware RAID that is often supported by ... GB partition for mirroring with a matching partition on the other disk. ... No need to do that if you have adequate backups. ...
    (comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware.storage)
  • Re: Program to do backups
    ... For backups, I like incremental mirroring from disk to disk on ... Under Linux, every night at 3am, a cron job runs the ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: Expert opinions on SATA, IDE drives, etc.
    ... also have several USB external drives, 100GB and 200GB, for backups. ... I collect a few opinions and facts on the old vs. new drives (sure, ... 2a) Is it that 2 SATA drives can be used to parallel-record files, ... I think what you are talking about is a RAID 1 (data mirroring) ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.help_and_support)