Re: Installing WinXp on a 2nd Hard Disk, on a System with w98(SE)



"Jeff Gaines" <jgaines_newsid@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:xn0eaqrnq1skh4000@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> On 08/12/2005 pmj wrote:
>
>> To do it (havin gmultiple w9x Installations) without that sort
>> of Faffing around does need a (3rd Party) Boot Manager, which
>> in itself introduces extra complications.
>
> I'm a bit confused why you think a boot manager introduces
> complications?

Only, really, cos what a (Independent, 3rd Party) Boot Manager does
is *completely* outside whatever windoze does (which, basically is the
point of it!) - soyes, taht enables you to do all sorts of stuff that
windoze has no idea about - but that can also lead to Confuzzlement,
when used by someone (such as Hawkeye?) who is just starting to find
out about this sort of thing?

>... You think that manually changing the active partition is easier!!!

No. not necessarily!
:-)

But actually, it's not at all difficult.

<snip>
>> OK - So I should have made 2 Partitions (on the 2nd Hard Disk),
>> first, before doing the WinXP Install? - Either using the
>> Partitioning thing in the WinXP Install Routine, or using FDisk
>> as originally discussed.
>> :-)
>
> That was the point of my test really. I wanted to know if the XP
> installer could create, say, a primary partition and an extended
> partition with logical drives and then allow you to choose one of the
> logical drives for the install.

Ah!...

>... I appreciate it can be installed anywhere but I was interested
> to know if the *installer* could/would loop round creating several
> partitions and then let you choose any of them.

Ah!
I see what you were getting at now!
:-)

Yes, it (the WinXP Partitioning thingy, that is part of the WinXP
Install Routine), can *definitely* do that - yes, you can "Loop"
around, Creating (&/or Deleting & ReCreating) whatever Partitions
you want[*1], until you have got the ones you want & *then* yo ucan
Select one of them to Install the WinXP into - it *still* though
(obviously?) always puts its actuall Boot Files onto the PFirst
Partition that is Marked as Active on the first Physical Hard Disk
(& incidentally, will tell you if it can't find one & will *attempt*
to Create one & Mark it as Active, if it can)

[*1] Subject to the proviso that you can't choose whether or not to
Create a Primary Partition or an Extended Partition (& neither can you
Create more than one Primary Partition on a Hard Disk, using it) -
it seems to always assume that the *first* Partition on a Hard Disk
will be a Primary Partition & any subsequent Partitions are Created
as Logical Drives within an Extended Partition.

(I *may* be a bit wrong (about the bit about the Primary Partition,
with 2nd Physical Hard Disks), but to answer your Query, yes basically
it will do what you asked - I can confirm it for definite if you want,
when I've tried it & compared how it does things on a *2nd* Physical
Hard Disk, rather than on an only Physical Hard Disk.

<snip>
>> Yes, it definitely is Possible - it (WinXP) can be Installed into
>> a Logical Drive in an Extended Partition no probs at all!
>
> I know that pmj!!!

OK! - But I didn't know that you knew that! Did I?
:-)
>From your Q I thought you were asking if it could be Installed
into (& would Boot up & Run OK from) a Logical Drive in an Extended
Partition...

>.. I wanted to know the installer's capabilities (see above).

Ah! OK - I see that *now*!
:-)

& yes (as mentioned above) the Install Routine can do what you asked
about it.

It's obviously(?) not as immediately obvious as some other ways of
doing it (& it's not a Graphical Utility), but it can do Deleting
& Creating of Partitions OK & it can Loop around, while you get them
how you want them, before then carrying on with the Installation itself.

--
pmj


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Partition and Dual Boot Vol IV (Options/Inclinations)
    ... installations of W98 and it's an easy way to achieve that. ... > to Create the otther Partitions (the Extended Partition & the Logical ... That doesn't achieve what he wants, without a boot manager anyway. ... >> allows you to install W98 on the new active drive. ...
    (uk.people.silversurfers)
  • Re: Techie advice please
    ... by having the motherboard look for certain coding on the hard disk before it will talk to said hard disk. ... They started off by selling only component parts and some people built their own computers using those parts. ... Next task is to install and dual boot to a *nix OS - this will be installed onto the fourth partition in effect. ...
    (uk.business.agriculture)
  • Re: To Partition, or not........
    ... >WinXP is also aimed at Home/Domestic Users whereas ... you basically *have* to Partition any Hard Disk ... the WinXP Install Routine has a Partitioning thingy in it. ...
    (uk.people.silversurfers)
  • Re: boot0 / LILO / GRUB: dual boot FreeBSD and Linux
    ... thing I found to be really cool is the FreeBSD boot manager. ... the boot record on the partition of your choice. ... install FreeBSD first and then Linux, but I will describe it the other ...
    (freebsd-questions)
  • Re: Hard Disk Corruption After Fail Hibernate Wakeup
    ... Try to install Ubuntu after formating Linux partition, ... Got fed up, format the entire hard disk, start from fresh and try to install Ubuntu. ...
    (comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware.storage)

Loading