Re: Strings!!



Paul Thorpe wrote:
I've just wasted an afternoon changing the strings on my Takamine acoustic
guitar .... twice!

I thought I'd try a change from my usual Martin 80:20 bronze (extra-light 10
to 47s) to some 'phosphor bronze'. I think I'd read that these had a warmer
sound.

The guitar shop had some Guvnor phosphor bronze similar gauge (10 to 48) at
the same price so I bought them. When I put them on the guitar the 3rd
string (22) buzzed horribly when fretted!
I even tried adjusting the truss rod in case they needed a bit more curve in
the neck ... but it didn't make any difference and besides I got the
feeling that it wasn't vibrating against the next fret ... the noise was
hard to identify.

Luckily I had a spare set of Martin strings so I just tried the 3rd from
this set, and the problem disappeared immediately.

So I removed all the Guvnor strings and replaced them with Martin and now it
sounds great again!

Anyone had a similar problem? .... is it because the string (.022) was
thinner than my usual .023 ... or is it the type of string .... or the
brand?

If the G string requires a lower tension than the Martin one, this could be just enough to cause buzzing due to the wider arc as it vibrates. All other things being equal (which they probably aren't, but never mind) a thinner string requires less tension for the same pitch, so this seems plausible.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Difference between Martin D28 and HD28
    ... Martin guitars for a long time. ... California from Mr. Bob Riskin owner of McCabe's guitar shop. ... are still in great condition and sound nice, ... for the Martin 12 String was born, ...
    (rec.music.makers.guitar.acoustic)
  • Re: Difference between Martin D28 and HD28
    ... it is a crummy guitar. ... Martin guitars for a long time. ... are still in great condition and sound nice, ... for the Martin 12 String was born, ...
    (rec.music.makers.guitar.acoustic)
  • Re: Golden opinions
    ... D’Addario beats out Elixir for No. 1 in the steel string division. ... Acoustic Guitar of the Year: Martin D-28. ... As far as D-28 and the Taylor over Collings rating... ...
    (rec.music.makers.guitar.acoustic)
  • Re: Difference between Martin D28 and HD28
    ... Martin guitars for a long time. ... California from Mr. Bob Riskin owner of McCabe's guitar shop. ... are still in great condition and sound nice, ... for the Martin 12 String was born, ...
    (rec.music.makers.guitar.acoustic)
  • Re: 10 string festival photos
    ... don't find the repertory written for 10 string guitar inot nteresting ... everyone's cup of tea (personally I love it, as I love and play all ... string guitar and the passion they had for it and for Yepes. ...
    (rec.music.classical.guitar)