Re: Ludicrous or great ?

Abo wrote:
Edward Cowling London UK wrote:
Part of me thought tonight was exciting, but to be honest it was ludicrously epic. Once the Dr saves all of reality across every multiverse where does he go next ? Saving an invasion of Perivale is going to seem a bit of an anti climax :-)

Seriously I'd like to see Sylvester & Sophie turn up in the Tardis and Sylvester wakes up and says "what a strange dream". Then someone sensible can start the new Dr Who sensibly !

Oh well it may have been crap, but I expect the kids liked it.


Towing the planet??? That made even me cringe a little...

Nice to see them not do a complete reset though. I wonder how the population of Earth would react to that? It looked like business as usual in the park where the Doctor dropped off Captain Jack and his new doctor and computer geek.


Yeah I thought the planet towing was a bit daft, especially how the moon just somehow popped back into orbit. Would have been better to have the TARDIS somehow wrap it's dematerialisation field around the Earth and rematerialise it back in position but back in time to the exact moment that it went missing, so no orbital disruption but still no "reset" either, since time has still passed on the Earth itself.

Otherwise I thought the episode was great, some very clever bits, especially resolving the Rose thing by giving her the Doctor she could never have otherwise had.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: The Stolen Earth: Absolute Rubbish... (SPOLIERS, OBVIOUSLY)
    ... Daleks invade Earth - that's all the plot ... The problem with it is that, Daleks invading earth is all ... Still, it's got a cracking Davros, ... And how's the Doctor going to come out of it, ...
    (rec.arts.drwho)
  • Re: Is Doctor Who "realistic" sci-fi?
    ... land on a planet with earth type gravity, ... Don't think the Doctor uses them, ... Earth and surely the Cylons will follow that somehow this leads to the ...
    (rec.arts.drwho)
  • Re: Is Doctor Who "realistic" sci-fi?
    ... land on a planet with earth type gravity, ... Don't think the Doctor uses them, ... Earth and surely the Cylons will follow that somehow this leads to the ...
    (rec.arts.drwho)
  • Re: Is Doctor Who "realistic" sci-fi?
    ... land on a planet with earth type gravity, ... Don't think the Doctor uses them, ... Earth and surely the Cylons will follow that somehow this leads to the ...
    (rec.arts.drwho)
  • Re: Is Doctor Who "realistic" sci-fi?
    ... land on a planet with earth type gravity, ... Don't think the Doctor uses them, ...
    (rec.arts.drwho)