Re: Police: illegal to get sexual gratification from innocuous pictures of children



Mike wrote:
MM wrote:
But no one will ever know as the police will say *any* picture of a
child, dressed or undressed, posed or not posed, that promotes sexual
gratification is an illegal image. And the "child" may be up to the
age of 18! This is more ludicrous than witch-burning in the Middle
Ages.

The "child" can be of *any* age - up to and beyond the age of eighteen.
A photograph of a fully dressed 35 year old could be "child porn" if a
jury thinks the picture is indecent (whatever that means) and the model
appears to be under eighteen. The model's true age is irrelevant.


I do believe that this is not how the law is actually interpreted and enforced. The wording of the relevant section of the Protection Of Children Act 1978 is:

(section 2 (3))

(3) In proceedings under this Act relating to indecent photographs of children a person is
to be taken as having been a child at any material time if it appears from the evidence as
a whole that he was then under the age of 18.

Therefore a birth certificate, a passport or some such compelling evidence would satisfy the requirements of this section. If the model is 35 and this is provable then it stands to reason that there is no offence. Yes, we've heard about people being prosecuted with models offering to fly in to give evidence in court but this seems to be an urban myth.


--
Robbie
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Mr. Kent Wills your kind attention
    ... If you want to hurt somebody, call them a pedophile. ... I do not advocate child pornography. ... 17 is the age of consent in Tokyo. ... a video of that sex within the USA? ...
    (misc.legal)
  • Re: FLDS Raid Costs 7.5 Million
    ... You obviously have no clue how long one minute lasts, to a child being raped. ... It doesn't take a vote of the people to determine that no adult should have the right under law to have sex with a child, or that search and seizure laws apply no matter how heinous the alleged crime may be. ... due process was not wrought in this case, why the warrant wasn't quashed later and the children returned till more information was gathered is beyond me, my opinion on what is a good age for marriage is null and void as i am not the person to decide that. ... The age for marriage with parental consent varies from state to state, and is lowest in - surprisingly - New Hampshire. ...
    (alt.gathering.rainbow)
  • Re: Technique recommendations for 6 year old
    ... > playing on a portable for 2 years and is in the Thompson Grade 2 Book. ... times a day for a couple weeks, the first many times a child this age ... Then all of a sudden I started listening to a tape that had Beethoven's ...
    (rec.music.makers.piano)
  • Re: Blairstapo to attack innocent babies
    ... >>How about compulsory child psychology classes for everyone over the ... because that really would be trying tom put the genie back into ... >youth is still learning how to behave. ... Wait until over the age of 30 ...
    (uk.legal)
  • Re: Possible Underage Beavers
    ... from Beavers. ... reasonable measures to ascertain the child's age and believed them to be at ... parents of the child knew that they were underage. ... The BSL cannot unilaterally amend ...
    (uk.rec.scouting)