Re: Computer tax set to replace TV licence fee ( Legal?)

In news:2miga2peh9voitac46dgk6qcbokpmojj5o@xxxxxxx,
Alex Heney <me8@xxxxxxxxxxx> typed:
On Sun, 02 Jul 2006 19:37:40 GMT, "Amanda Angelika"
<manic_mandy@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Computer tax set to replace TV licence fee
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,2-1508650,00.html


A very stupid headline, since that was only one of several options
that *might* be looked at by 2017.


My question is would a taxation on computers and/or Internet access
contravene article 10 of the European convention on Human rights?


No. Of course not.

Computers and internet access are already taxed (VAT).

There's VAT on Pens, Paper and Ink to. Howver one doesn't need a special
licence to own a pen and paper or to use such tools. One already has an
inalianable licence to use such tools, or at least one should do in a
democratic society. What makes Computers and Internet access any different?

Article 10 - Freedom of expression
1. Everyone has the right to freedom of expression. This right shall
include freedom to hold opinions and to receive and impart
information and ideas without interference by public authority and
regardless of frontiers.

Whilst I understand this act has not been used successfully in the
abolition of the Licence in regard to Television sets because
European law also allows member states to licence broadcasting,
television or cinema enterprises. Surely when it comes to computers
and Internet access, whilst both may be used to consume
entertainment and limited broadcast material are primarily used as a
means of interactive communication where the user may in fact
express and create more than he or she may actually consume.

Surely any taxation of such a medium would in effect constitute a
tax of free expression and would fundamentally contravene European
human rights legislation as well as being completely against the
Interests of democracy in the UK whether real or illusionary.

Nope.

There is nothing in Article 10 which states that "freedom of
expression" must be "free of charge".

No but charging is a limitation which disenfrancises the poor and would in
effect removes basic human rights, making such rights comensurate to wealth.

Such imbalances exist in any case due to free market economics. In a
democracy part of a goverments role is to redress such imbalances. Othewise
why would one actuall need a Govenement at all?


Nor that specific media for expressing opinion in must be free.

No but generally in a democracy part of the governments role is to uphold
democracy itself to ensure that no one is disenfranchised from access to the
means of expression, freedom of speech and political discourse. In fact the
UK government fund schemes with bring computers and Internet access to
school children in poorer areas and to the unemployed and other poor people.
There are also many free computer courses available. Anything which would
serve to disenfranchise or limit access to the means of expression, would
seem to be at variance with the Job a democratic government is entrusted to
perform.

Democracy is IMO far more important that the funding of the BBC, which as a
part of the establishment it could be agued is not entirely independent and
is an oracle of government propaganda and social manipulation.

--
Amanda




.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Computer tax set to replace TV licence fee ( Legal?)
    ... licence to own a pen and paper or to use such tools. ... What makes Computers and Internet access any different? ... Interests of democracy in the UK whether real or illusionary. ...
    (uk.legal)
  • ---The New Politics of Political Aid in Venezuela
    ... the U.S. government ... In the name of promoting democracy and freedom, ... president of Venezuela. ... Freedom House is best known for its widely cited Freedom in the World ...
    (soc.culture.venezuela)
  • Re: [Democracy_forBurma] http://www.anawma.com/dynamite-1.htm
    ... Life and death is not something for the government to decide about, ... I do compare Burma under Than ... reluctant to cooperate, sabotaging the democracy. ... The junta alleges that the development towards a multi-party democracy ...
    (soc.culture.burma)
  • Re: Campaigning is a Science, too.
    ... How else can you explain the long tenure of Senator Robert ... reinforced by the irresponsible media—slaps at the face of democracy. ... decline in our government and in our lives. ... media will allow to be aired. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Democracy is DOA
    ... Democracy rocks. ... weren't about to vote him out any time soon. ... entertainment to be sure, but horrible government. ... Bob Dole or Bill Clinton would have still been President. ...
    (alt.gathering.rainbow)