Re: falsify



Reinhard Mick wrote:
Hello!

Yesterday I had a kind of discussion about the meaning of the verb "to
falsify".

In my first language the same word ("falsifizieren") only means to
proof that a theory is not true (and therefore has to be abandoned).
It is - to my knowledge - used in this scientific context only and has
a similar meaning as "to disprove" - like measuring of the precession
of the perihelion of mercury "falsified"(?) the newtonian theory of
mechanics.

I just translated it directly in a slightly different context and was
misunderstood completely, because to falsify, as I was told, has the
meaning of intentionally making a false document, e.g. printing false
money or false passports.

My question, which I could not resolve by my dictionaries or the
internet is: Can "falsify" also have the meaning of "disprove", at
least in a scientific context?

In my opinion, no. One 'contradicts' or 'disproves' a theory. 'Falsify'
is only used int he sense you give above.


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: falsify
    ... Yesterday I had a kind of discussion about the meaning of the verb "to ... In my first language the same word only means to ... It is - to my knowledge - used in this scientific context only and has ... misunderstood completely, because to falsify, as I was told, has the ...
    (uk.culture.language.english)
  • Re: falsify
    ... Yesterday I had a kind of discussion about the meaning of the verb "to ... It is - to my knowledge - used in this scientific context only and has ... misunderstood completely, because to falsify, as I was told, has the ... Thanks in advance for any help and greetings from Austria! ...
    (uk.culture.language.english)
  • falsify
    ... Yesterday I had a kind of discussion about the meaning of the verb "to ... misunderstood completely, because to falsify, as I was told, has the ... (When I want to find a translation of a german word, ... that is known to offer an extended variety of translations ...
    (uk.culture.language.english)
  • Re: Why? [was Re: Cantor`s powerset theorem is false?]
    ... the falsfiability criterion was more from science than math. ... As has already been pointed out, existentials are hard to falsify ... Meaning in the logical context arguably comes from proofs. ...
    (sci.logic)