Re: March for Tibet's Independence 2006

bmoore@xxxxxxx wrote:
In that case what is the so called Tibet Independence Movement and
Hong
Independence Movement about? What are they supposed to be independent
from?

Pretty clearly, from China. Not sure what your point is.

22/7

Let's see what was being post:

1) LeoKin wrote:
Tibet is part a China, Hong Kong SAR is too

2) You disagreed and rediculed LeoKin.

That means you believe that Tibet and Hong Kong are not part of China.
If they are not part of China and they are already independent, then
what is the fuss about the so called Hong Kong Independent Movement and
the Tibetan Independent movement.

May be you are saying that Hong Kong is not part of China, not already
indepenet but part of the United Kingdom, then the HIM should be about
independence from the United Kingdom.

May be you are saying that Tibet is not part of China, not already
indepenet but part of the "I don't know what", then the TIM should be
about independence from the "I don't know what".

On the other hand, if you are saying that the HIM and TIM are seeking
independence "Pretty clearly, from China", then that means Hong Kong
and Tibet are at least for now, and thought it should not have been,
could not have been and would not have been, part of China.

There is nothing to argue about the statement that Hong Kong and Tibet
are part of China as it says nothing about Hong Kong and Tibet should
be, would be, could be, should have been, would have been or could have
been.

22/7

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Legal Basis of Building a Free Hong Kong 20080901
    ... Hong Konger Front, calling for Hong Kong independence and the ... China will not accept the facts you stated because there were no ... China is not that naive to let Hongkong be an independent state -- ...
    (soc.culture.singapore)
  • Re: iefectu koshova, muzika si idepedentza
    ... Bjork has a track record of courting controversy and surprising her ... China by shouting "Tibet! ... Talk of Tibetan independence is considered taboo in China, ...
    (soc.culture.romanian)
  • Re: iefectu koshova, muzika si idepedentza
    ... Bjork has a track record of courting controversy and surprising her ... China by shouting "Tibet! ... Talk of Tibetan independence is considered taboo in China, ...
    (soc.culture.romanian)
  • Re: iefectu koshova, muzika si idepedentza
    ... Bjork has a track record of courting controversy and surprising her ... China by shouting "Tibet! ... Talk of Tibetan independence is considered taboo in China, ...
    (soc.culture.romanian)
  • Free Tibet. And what about Kashmir?
    ... Violent protests in Tibet and a subsequent crackdown by the Beijing ... Indians who do so are hypocritical to boot. ... Moreover, were such a nation to split from China, it would feel ... accept genuine autonomy instead of the complete independence he had ...
    (talk.politics.misc)