Re: Israeli IDF Report of June 1948 Concluded that 70% of Palestinian Exodus Caused by Haganah/IDF Operations and Activities of Dissident Jewish Organizations. (was: When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?)
- From: "peace.seeker.27" <vesuvian.doppelgange@xxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Tue, 20 May 2008 08:18:21 -0700 (PDT)
On May 19, jgarbuz <jgar...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On May 19, "peace.seeker.27" <vesuvian.doppelga...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
"The crux of the Palestinian Problem is the fate of a people and its
homeland. It is the piecemeal conquest and continued seizure of the
entire country by military force. It is the forcible dispossession and
displacement of the bulk of the indigenous population, and the
subjugation of the rest. It is also the massive importation of alien
colonists - to replace the evicted and lord it over the conquered."
First of all, I don't believe a Left wing Jew anymore than I do a
Communist, a Nazi or an Islamofascist.
That makes you a bigot: a person obstinately or intolerantly devoted
to his or her own opinions and prejudices; especially : one who
regards or treats the members of a group (as a racial or ethnic group)
with hatred and intolerance.
jgarbuz does not deny being a bigot.
I treat the Arabs the way Muhammad treated my people in Medina. And
the way they treated us from 1921 onwards, especially in 1929. Muslims
started terrorism. I believe in fighting fire with fire.
But even if all the above was true, so what?
Then there is little difference between the methods used by the Nazis
and the methods used by the Zionists, as your own words confirm:
The JEwish people had a
RIGHT to use ANY MEANS NECESSARY to get back their homeland, including
invasion, murder. deceit, ethnic cleansing, or whatever you want to
call it.
Good. I don't want my people to be any different than your people. I
don't want Jews to live to any "higher standard."
I just want they be normal, like everybody else. That would be good
enough for me.
Translation: Nazi methods are good enough for me.
Is this an example of the higher ethical standards that the Jewish
people adhere to?<
Jews are supposed to live according to the Torah, which among other
things tells us to kill those who come to kill us first, and to wipe
Amalek off the face of the earth.
… so genocide is OK in your book.
It's not about living up to some
left wing dystopian and hypocritical standards of their own design.
… so in your version, Jewish ethics is the law of the jungle.
The Torah tells us that the Land of Israel is Jewish land,
… and what are the boundaries of Jewish land? Is it the Nile river
to the Persian gulf? If so, you have much more killing to do. Do
not ask me for any help.
and anyone
who denies us the right to our homeland is an enemy. It does not tell
us to "turn the other cheek." That is your version. You go live by it.-
You are incorrect in your assumption concerning my religion.
.
- Follow-Ups:
- References:
- When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?
- From: Shlomo
- Israeli IDF Report of June 1948 Concluded that 70% of Palestinian Exodus Caused by Haganah/IDF Operations and Activities of Dissident Jewish Organizations. (was: When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?)
- From: peace.seeker.27
- Re: Israeli IDF Report of June 1948 Concluded that 70% of Palestinian Exodus Caused by Haganah/IDF Operations and Activities of Dissident Jewish Organizations. (was: When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?)
- From: Shlomo
- Re: Israeli IDF Report of June 1948 Concluded that 70% of Palestinian Exodus Caused by Haganah/IDF Operations and Activities of Dissident Jewish Organizations. (was: When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?)
- From: peace.seeker.27
- Re: Israeli IDF Report of June 1948 Concluded that 70% of Palestinian Exodus Caused by Haganah/IDF Operations and Activities of Dissident Jewish Organizations. (was: When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?)
- From: jgarbuz
- Re: Israeli IDF Report of June 1948 Concluded that 70% of Palestinian Exodus Caused by Haganah/IDF Operations and Activities of Dissident Jewish Organizations. (was: When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?)
- From: peace.seeker.27
- Re: Israeli IDF Report of June 1948 Concluded that 70% of Palestinian Exodus Caused by Haganah/IDF Operations and Activities of Dissident Jewish Organizations. (was: When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?)
- From: jgarbuz
- When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?
- Prev by Date: Re: Israeli IDF Report of June 1948 Concluded that 70% of Palestinian Exodus Caused by Haganah/IDF Operations and Activities of Dissident Jewish Organizations. (was: When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?)
- Next by Date: Dragons of Islam, remember your origin....
- Previous by thread: Re: Israeli IDF Report of June 1948 Concluded that 70% of Palestinian Exodus Caused by Haganah/IDF Operations and Activities of Dissident Jewish Organizations. (was: When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?)
- Next by thread: Re: Israeli IDF Report of June 1948 Concluded that 70% of Palestinian Exodus Caused by Haganah/IDF Operations and Activities of Dissident Jewish Organizations. (was: When will the Arabs admit that they caused their own naqba?)
- Index(es):