Re: USS Liberty: What MTB Personnel Would Have Seen



Strange; it appears to be the view that is claimed the attacking jet
pilots would have seen (from Bamford):

"Not only did the ship have ?GTR-5? painted broadly on both sides of
its bow and stern, it also had its name painted in large, bold, black
letters: 'U.S.S. LIBERTY.'"

But more to the point, as to sworn eyewitness testimony regarding the
MTBs:

"At this time the torpedo boats, three of them, that had torpedoed us,
were laying off, waiting for us to sink, I believe."

"Immediately after the ship was struck by the torpedo, the torpedo
boats stopped dead in the water and milled around astern of the ship at
a range of approximately 500 to 800 yards. One of the boats signalled
by flashing light, in English, 'do you require assistance'? "

Available from: http://www.ussliberty.org/nci.txt

And from the crew's own submitted chronology (Exhibit 27):

<start>
1440 MTB'S STANDING AWAY FROM THE SHIP. ONE MTB HAS HULL NUMBER 206-17

1503 ONE MTB RETURNED TO SHIP AND SIGNALLED "DO YOU NEED HELP" IN
ENGLISH C.O. SIGNALLED "NEGATIVE"

1505 MTB'S RETIRED TOWARD SHORE
<end>

Available here: http://libertyincident.com/USNcourt.htm

Not surprisingly, not one word as to what is claimed the photo
represents.

MW

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Battleships...again......
    ... I'll put 4 torps into the hull of your battleship. ... Neither was hit by as many as four bombs, yet one sank, and the ... battleships some cover from both of the original torpedo delivery ... is a ship killing bomb, a ship killing torpedo, or a ship killing anti ...
    (sci.military.naval)
  • Re: Designing a Raider today-how would one go about it?
    ... As a base I use Columbo Express container ship, ... - A few RIB's for assault teams. ... Heavy Russian 650mm torpedoes in underwater torpedo tubes. ...
    (sci.military.naval)
  • Re: Battleships...again......
    ... I'll put 4 torps into the hull of your battleship. ... Neither was hit by as many as four bombs, yet one sank, and the ... battleships some cover from both of the original torpedo delivery ... is a ship killing bomb, a ship killing torpedo, or a ship killing anti ...
    (sci.military.naval)
  • Re: Pearl Harbor BBs
    ... envision using BBs (or any other sort of ship) ... Japanese torpedo that hit USS North Carolina was intended for a carrier ... There was a small wisp of smoke ... time she made a port turn and headed for us. ...
    (sci.military.naval)
  • Re: Explosive force
    ... > blown apart can be sunk by a torpedo. ... > Afterall the water rushing in isn't from 'it's explosive force alone'. ... no "ship of the line"-equivalent ... into the hole, or more precisely the fact that when it lands, all the ...
    (rec.games.frp.gurps)