Re: Medical Research


"Herman Rubin" <hrubin@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:e48jb2$1cj8@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Statistical significance says absolutely nothing about the
magnitude of the effect, nor does its lack.

Whether a treatment is good is not changed by collecting
data, and intelligent decision making will cause the use of
many treatments before that much information is present.

Suppose you had a disease which was about 50% lethal, and
you gave a million people each a placebo or a treatment.
Suppose the difference of the survival rates was 1% in
favor of the treatment. That is extremely significant, so
much so that one could say it was proved that the treatment
had an effect. I suggest that an experimental treatment
which has cured three out of three is a better bet,
although this is not statistically significant.

Well, Herman, that is just what Skeptic did to me. He sent me to look at
a study with a lot of faults which had a test of significance where,
according to the study, "The absolute reduction in the risk of death after
10 years is small" but signficant statistically on the other hand. Small.
So you pretty well predicted the response from Skeptic. Now what?



.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Fuchss Cornea Dystrophy Questions
    ... age-related macular degeneration is one of the most common eye ... earlier no treatment was available, in the recent decade an antioxidant ... The difference was statistically significant as compared to the ...
    (sci.med.vision)
  • Re: HOW TO MAKE YOUR BODY ALKALINE?
    ... Then there's the study about CsCl use in chemotherapy treatment that Corey ... Arbitrarily small differences can be "statistically significant" if the ...
    (rec.martial-arts)
  • Re: HOW TO MAKE YOUR BODY ALKALINE?
    ... > Then there's the study about CsCl use in chemotherapy treatment that Corey ... Fourth, a "statistically significant" ...
    (rec.martial-arts)
  • Re: Medical Research
    ... Whether a treatment is good is not changed by collecting ... "The absolute reduction in the risk of death after ... but it would not have been statistically significant. ...
    (talk.politics.medicine)
  • Re: Medical Research
    ... Whether a treatment is good is not changed by collecting ... "The absolute reduction in the risk of death ... but it would not have been statistically significant. ... you might just want to know your risk of dying is less if you ...
    (talk.politics.medicine)