Re: Please keep your *RETARDS* in restraints. (invariable genome-retry)
- From: John Harshman <jharshman@xxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Sun, 29 Nov 2009 17:10:18 -0800
spintronic wrote:
Can an organism with a preset genome evolve to various enviroments,
*without* changing a single letter of it's genome?
Still no.
Strictly speaking, organisms don't evolve at all. Populations evolve. And of course evolution requires some form of variation.
(Specifically, I am reffering to "minimal cell" organisms, and
ignoring [stricktly enforcing] mutation to their genome)
That's a problem. Even adaptation (different from evolution) would seem to be beyond a minimal cell. Evolved flexibility is one sort of adaptation, but it isn't evolution and wouldn't happen in a minimal cell. Recombination is a possibility, but there are two problems with this: 1) minimal cells wouldn't be capable of recombination and 2) you need some variation in the population, and how did it get there if the genome is preset?
Further, I am implying that (If we allowed for mutation [which we
don't] those mutations are filtered out by whatever means)
Then no evolution is possible. Please explain.
.
- References:
- Please keep your *RETARDS* in restraints. (invariable genome-retry)
- From: spintronic
- Please keep your *RETARDS* in restraints. (invariable genome-retry)
- Prev by Date: Re: News: Chimps Enjoy a Good Tune, Too.
- Next by Date: Re: The claim of mountains of evidence for the ORIGIN of biological
- Previous by thread: Re: Please keep your *RETARDS* in restraints. (invariable
- Next by thread: News: Origin of Life: Generating RNA Molecules in Water
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|