Re: adman and the truth

[M]adman schreef:
Devils Advocaat wrote:
On 27 Mar, 13:50, "[M]adman" <g...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Devils Advocaat wrote:
On 27 Mar, 07:25, "[M]adman" <g...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Devils Advocaat wrote:
On 26 Mar, 23:31, "[M]adman" <g...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
unrestrained_h...@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
On Mar 26, 2:51 pm, Burkhard <b.scha...@xxxxxxxx> wrote:
On 26 Mar, 20:06, "[M]adman" <g...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
reddfr...@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
On Mar 26, 10:51 am, "[M]adman" <g...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
<cut>
I see you cannot tell the difference between fantasy and
history
The same could be said about you. How, exactly do you tell
that difference? Why are stories about dragons fantasy, while
stories about a global flood are history? Why are stories
about flying serpents fantasy, but stories about a talking
one history?
Do you expect me to BELIEVE that you cannot tell the
difference between "Mobi Dick", " Robin Hood" and texts like
"Indian Sanskrit"?
1) Mobi Dick (fiction)
2) Robin Hood (fiction but prolly based on some type of real
character and folk lore from an older period in time)
3) Sanskrit (Indian Historical Records)
Sanskrit is a language, not an "Indian historical record"
Though some of them are IN Sanskrit
It's statements of his like this one that disabused me of the
notion that he might be a lay expert in mythology, religion, and
culture.
Kermit
The VEDAS happy?
And the Sanskrit is also mathmatics
I use English to describe matters biological, does that mean
English is biology?
Of course it doesn't.
Sanskrit is a language, nothing more.
It is not "Indian historical records".
It is not "mathematics".
And as far as I know, the Vedas are not historical records either.
The Rig Veda is a collection of hymns.
The Yajur Veda and the Sama Veda are collections of formulas (not
mathematical ones by the way).
And the Sama Veda is a collection of spells, incantations,
stories, predictions, warding charms and some speculative hymns.
It would seem to me then, the Vedas are not historical records
either.
You are not too bright then
Why don't you present any section of any of the four Vedic texts
that actually is a verifiable historical account and prove me wrong?
Just one?

[snipped for brevity]

snipped for dishonesty

Here ya go, the following describes a history Rig Veda:

A great war broke out in the remote old days between the Indian
Aryans and the Phoenicians in which the latter were defeated and
compelled to leave wholly or partially the land of the Aryans. [the
bible mentions a great war]
[snipped for brevity]

snipped for dishonesty

And you fall at the first hurdle.

I didn't ask for some modern interpretation of a section of one of the
Vedic texts, I asked for a section of any of the four Vedic texts that
actually is a verifiable historical account and prove me wrong?

So despite your alleged knowledge of the ancient texts you seem
unwilling to do this one simple thing.

Why is that?

Never expect me to take the time that i did to respond to you in such detail again. I have never seen such intellectual dishonesty collected in one place. Ever.

All of it is in the Vedas, including the descriptions of nuclear war are in the Vedas as well. I gave you links to scientists that understand the Vedas. Did you want me to give you chapter and verse? Baby-sit you and spoon feed you your knowledge?

I gave you enough information to make some discoveries of your own. You refuse to do that.

Like i said (that you dishonestly cut out) YOU just do not want to search for truth, you simply want a reason NOT to believe in God.

Well, your theory of evolution. which is a joke, gives you that reason.



Its interesting, because you ignore the fact that many evolutionists here spoon feed you every day, but you refuse to listen, and everytime they ask you for the "original" you cry and turn your head the other way like a baby.

Come now Madman, don't be a hypocrite.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: adman and the truth
    ... Why are stories about dragons fantasy, ... but stories about a talking one history? ... The VEDAS are history in story form even ... Veda in Sanskrit means knowledge. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: adman and the truth
    ... Why are stories about dragons fantasy, ... but stories about a talking one history? ... "The pre-Classical form of Sanskrit is known as Vedic Sanskrit, ... The VEDAS are history in story form even poetic form ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: adman and the truth
    ... Why are stories about dragons fantasy, ... about a global flood are history? ... could also reference the VEDAS. ... Veda in Sanskrit means knowledge. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: adman and the truth
    ... Why are stories about dragons fantasy, ... stories about a global flood are history? ... some of them are IN Sanskrit ... Panini's work not just in the German translation by Bothlink, ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: adman and the truth
    ... Why are stories about dragons fantasy, ... but stories about a talking one history? ... some of them are IN Sanskrit ... The VEDAS are history in story form even ...
    (talk.origins)