Re: Phylogenetic question for John Harshman



spintronic schreef:
A new life form develops and has a single unit of
Heredity. Denoted by a single letter.


Upon every successive modification we re-catagorise
the gene using the next letter in the alphabet. The first
one is "A", & With time, this unit starts to undergo
modification, "A" --->"B", "B" --->"C" etc.

Eventually a new unit of heriditary is gained, which also
undergoes it's own modification, etc etc.

I have placed each unit in a horizontal array. With each box depicted
by integers in the order the genes were gained horizontally.
Our first unit undergoes 3 modifications.

. 1
[A]
[B]
[C]

Either generation now picks up a new unit of Heredity [B] for example,
which now becomes

.1 . 2
[A]
[B][A]
[C]

Then another one

. 1 . 2
[A][A]
[B][A]
[C]

Now either units can undergo modification
. 1. 2
[A][B]
[C][A]
[C][A]

Etc etc.

With an array upto 5 genes (Obviously more could be
added, but for simplicity... ) (And "-" denotes no unit yet)


.1 . 2 . 3. 4 . 5
[A] [-] [-] [-] [-]


Could you make any nested hierarchy you like, as
detailed as possible?

I suppose that in such a simple setup, we would not
get a nested tree but a graph, because one node
can have multiple ancestor nodes, as in your
example, where [CA] develops from both [C] and
[BA]. It would be an oriented graph if development
only happens in the sequence A>B>C..., and only
additions are possible, not deletions.

Because of the much greater complexity of real
"hereditary units" a graph is unlikely in the
extreme in real life.

Regards,

Karel
--
If knowledge can create problems,
it is not through ignorance that we can solve them (Asimov)

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Phylogenetic question for John Harshman
    ... Denoted by a single letter. ... by integers in the order the genes were gained horizontally. ... Either generation now picks up a new unit of Heredity for example, ... Now either units can undergo modification ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Phylogenetic question for John Harshman
    ... Denoted by a single letter. ... by integers in the order the genes were gained horizontally. ... Either generation now picks up a new unit of Heredity for example, ... Now either units can undergo modification ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Phylogenetic question for John Harshman
    ... Denoted by a single letter. ... the gene using the next letter in the alphabet. ... Either generation now picks up a new unit of Heredity for example, ... Now either units can undergo modification ...
    (talk.origins)
  • "Genes are followers not leaders". Was: Birds of feather...
    ... of genes in heredity and evolution as expressed in her Developmental Plasticity ... have control systems for maintaining their structure and function. ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Re: "Genes are followers not leaders". Was: Birds of feather...
    ... > biologists still believe that genes determine the heredity of all the ... > synonymous to heredity and hereditary!). ... > a growing minority of distinguished biologists that do not endorse that view, ... the issue of whether genetic or environmental inheritance ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)