Re: COMPLAINT ABOUT MODERATION

On Jul 6, 9:10 pm, Dale Kelly <THIS_IS_A_SPAMT...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Fri, 06 Jul 2007 21:40:08 +0000, David Iain Greig wrote:
If he would exhibit self-control I would at least have the faint hope
that he would be able to act as a poster in good-standing.

David, my posts tend to be esoteric because I am an esoteric thinker, I
do believe, in most of my recent posts, I have gotten around to the topic
of origins, whether that be of life or cosmology, cosmology does have
implications on life

You snipped the bit the post you're responding to where he details why
he's on your case, and it is not because you are an "esoteric
thinker." It's the nym-shifting and abuse of other groups that's
primarily getting him down.

I do not see how I can predict what you consider on or off topic, without
you specifying this in the charter, to really censor topic fairly you
would need to turn off the bot and do the moderation by hand

to make your part in this easier, I won't crosspost for awhile, but as a
liberal, I really think you have developed an unhealthy vested interest
in the outcome of what should be a free debate

Did he actually threaten to ban you if you went off-topic, or did he
just offer and opinion that you were off-topic? I continue to agree
that he should not threaten to ban you for going off-topic, but as
other people have mentioned he's free to have an opinion.

there is a difference between a temporal disruption and a complete
destruction of the group, did Jabriol or Ed Conrad, etc., really take the
group to the point no return, or were they just an itch on the surface of
someone who has developed a control complex?

Jabriol cross-posted messages to suicide support groups urging people
to kill themselves to further the goals of evolution. He also cross-
posted messages to rape support groups telling them that it was good
they were raped. You'll not earn yourself much sympathy supporting
him.

As nearly as I can tell Ed Conrad kept shifting his name to avoid
killfiles, which is not legal behavior. It isn't that hard to play by
the rules.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: COMPLAINT ABOUT MODERATION
    ... David, my posts tend to be esoteric because I am an esoteric thinker, I ... of origins, whether that be of life or cosmology, cosmology does have ... are really reflective of the fact that you do not have a somber attitude ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: I came here for information and advice
    ... preaching Jesus, and on a cardiology board, it's simply not appropriate. ... with constant posts about religion. ... I'm sure there are plenty of moderated cardiology support groups that do not ... Sorry you are having concerns about your medication, ...
    (sci.med.cardiology)
  • Re: Talk.origins unmoderated
    ... overzealousness. ... One is Ed Conrad, who posts here all the time by making new accounts, ... who likes to post to suicide support groups that ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: NEWSGROUP HELP NEEDED
    ... reading the volume of posts. ... There's an answer in Motzarella's FAQ about this. ... support groups I think you have to set your authorizations to automatically ...
    (rec.arts.mystery)
  • Re: Talk.origins unmoderated
    ... Lift the moderation, as the moderator is nazi like in his ... overzealousness. ... One is Ed Conrad, who posts here all the time by making new accounts, ... who likes to post to suicide support groups that ...
    (talk.origins)