Re: Policy asked to investigate entropy-claim in website of Turku University in Finland



On Apr 1, 11:25 am, "Robert Carnegie" <rja.carne...@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Perplexed in Peoria wrote:

it remains the case that each photon we receive from the sun
*increases* the entropy of the Earth. And that was the
entirely correct point of the entirely stupid creationist who
called in the cops. And then the university spokesman showed
himself to be even stupider by saying that analyzing the
thermodynamics of this situation is a Nobel-prize level
research topic.


It hasn't been explained simply enough for me that "each
photon we receive from the sun *increases* the entropy of the
Earth".

I am certainly willing to provide a simple (and probably wrong
too) explanation of this.

To keep things simple, imagine that everything of importance
occurs exclusively in the atmosphere. Now imagine that the
atmosphere is in a bottle (which in a way it is). If the
atmosphere was at zero entropy it would be lying at the bottom
of the bottle as a rectangle (or maybe as a platonic chair).

From now on every time a photon hits the chair energy is added,
increasing the entropy of the chair until it finally decays
into a cloud of gas. If you add more energy to the gas, entropy
*increases* even more.

Cordially;

Friar Broccoli
Robert Keith Elias, Quebec, Canada Email: EliasRK (of) gmail * com
Best programmer's & all purpose text editor: http://www.semware.com

--------- I consider ALL arguments in support of my views ---------

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Entropy question
    ... > heats up as entropy increase, while the gas in the laboratory cools ... > down as entropy increases. ... Modern statistical mechanics is an approximation to QFT. ... energy together form the energy-momentum 4-vector. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Gasoline vs. battery
    ... Entropy invites the idea that changing H2O to HHO should ... HHO is just a simpler form of water. ... In short, two water molecules, with the addition of energy to break the bonds ... will form two molecules of hydrogen gas and one molecule of oxygen gas. ...
    (sci.chem.electrochem.battery)
  • Re: Entropy question
    ... > space do the opposite and condense, entropy increases as well. ... Start with a uniform gas in an otherwise empty region. ... the cube of the Jeans length -- it will begin to collapse into lumps. ... energy away from the lumps. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Entropy question
    ... >> I remember reading an account of the fact that when a gas expands ... >> space do the opposite and condense, entropy increases as well. ... > the cube of the Jeans length -- it will begin to collapse into lumps. ... > energy away from the lumps. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Gravity Inside A Cylinder
    ... > |> have no gaseous atmosphere, there being a lower potential energy state ... > |> entropy change of the system is negligable compared to the resulting ... equilbrium temperature profile was isothermal. ... would manifestly not minimize potential energy: ...
    (sci.physics)

Loading