Re: Children of men




Iain wrote:


You'll find that sci-fi has come on a lot since the Thirties.

The premise is stupid. I shall not attend.

How do you know the premise is stupid? Maybe toward the end of the
film, the reason why women became infertile is revealed.

I suppose it's revealed early on. The story concerns ONE woman who
somehow managed to get pregnant, who is immune to the plague or
whatever. She is the most valuable human on Earth and everyone wants to
get her, to get her child as they would be the last hope for mankind.
Her existence is a secret, and some guy has to get her from one place
to another intact.

The premise to Jurassic Park is in some ways stupid, but it's based on
a loosely valid concept, and doesn't make the "what if humans tried to
run a dinosaur safari" motif any less interesting.

I liked JP. The premise is reasonable and convincing. That of COM is
not.

Furthermore, it sounds reasonable to me that the onset of human
extinction would provoke war amongst some factions, especially
religious ones.

Go watch it and tell me what you think. It's coming out in a couple of
months.

~Iain

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: If I was...
    ... >>>You cannot seriously be this stupid. ... >>Dude, your ignorance regarding racism is beginning to astound. ... would vote for a black candidate for the same reason. ... you have no understanding that it isn't relieved by voting for a ...
    (misc.writing)
  • Re: If I was...
    ... >>You cannot seriously be this stupid. ... >>>as well as whites are. ... >Dude, your ignorance regarding racism is beginning to astound. ... You haven't given one good reason for considering black racism to be ...
    (misc.writing)
  • Re: For Buzz; The Answer
    ... You realized that my purpose of government being *protecting the ... it's become what Dave is. ... sunuvabitch," nor have you given any reason for government. ... Well, maybe not stupid, just a fool. ...
    (misc.news.internet.discuss)
  • Re: can BD organize a MIT seminar?? ; #112; 2nd ed; Euclid
    ... And probably another reason Bill Dubuque wants you to ... Iain Davidson further writes: ... Do you think that 100 has two digits or three ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: can BD organize a MIT seminar?? ; #112; 2nd ed; Euclid
    ... And probably another reason Bill Dubuque wants you to ... Iain Davidson further writes: ... Do you think that 100 has two digits or three ...
    (sci.math)