Re: YEC meets the expanding earth


Robert Carnegie kirjoitti:

Mark Isaak wrote:
In the latest Acts & Facts from the ICR, Dr. Humphreys responds to some
questions from the first RATE (Radioisotopes and the Age of the Earth, or
somesuch) conference.

Begin quoting --------------

Q: Wouldn't accellerated nuclear decay generate a lot of heat? Is that a
problem?

Yes, it's a problem we've been thinking about from the beginning of the
project, and we have the beginnings of some answers. We have several
lines of observational evidence that *volume cooling*, unusual removal of
heat from the entire volume of a rock, occurred at the same time the
accelerated decay was occurring. A little-known feature of Einstein's
General Relativity Theory suggests that such cooling resulted from a
cosmological effect, the rapid expansion of space during the same periods
as rapid decay happened, such as during the Genesis Flood. I discuss
these matters in both Volume I (pp. 369-373) and Volume II (pp. 67-74) of
the RATE techincal book series.

That's idiotic.

(Yeah, I should tell you something you don't know.)

He appears to be referring to inflation. But inflation isn't in
General Relativity.

He's also proposing a sudden burst of accelerated radioactive decay
coincident with the Flood. Presumably whatever God did to send a Flood
also accelerated radioactivity. But wouldn't that leave not a wide
range of radioactive dates in rocks, but only pre-Flood rocks with one
vast apparent age, and post-Flood rocks that are identifiably young?

It would make more sense - not much more, but more - to suppose that
the water of the Flood cooled the overheated rocks.

Steam cooking Noah and the Ark in the process. :)

-- Wakboth

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: YEC meets the expanding earth
    ... Wouldn't accellerated nuclear decay generate a lot of heat? ... such as during the Genesis Flood. ... range of radioactive dates in rocks, but only pre-Flood rocks with one ... vast apparent age, and post-Flood rocks that are identifiably young? ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: OT: Racial superiority / Intelligent design was Re: OT:Thanksgiving
    ... Please give some *reasonable* hypothesis of how polonium particles could ... any other decay that could produce the polonium. ... Gentry rationalizes any evidence ... 3.The rocks at two of the sites are not even granites but calcite ...
    (comp.lang.cobol)
  • Re: Evidence Against an Old Earth of Billions of Years: originalsource
    ... > Pleistocene (Ice Age) strata that does not contain significant amounts ... > Uranium and thorium generate helium atoms as they decay to lead. ... > Age' was much shorter than evolutionists think, ... Comets disintegrate too quickly. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Age dating question
    ... several methods for dating regarding, say, the age of the earth, or a ... rate of decay, one calculate the age of the object in question. ... observes another person reading a book. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Evidence Against an Old Earth of Billions of Years.
    ... > Pleistocene (Ice Age) strata that does not contain significant amounts ... > Uranium and thorium generate helium atoms as they decay to lead. ... > Age' was much shorter than evolutionists think, ... Comets disintegrate too quickly. ...
    (talk.origins)