Re: Dembski's Blog responds (sort of)


Elf M. Sternberg wrote:
"Zachriel" <angelmailNOSPAM@xxxxxxxxxxxx> writes:

Ecological divergence exhibits consistently positive associations with
reproductive isolation across disparate taxa
http://www.pnas.org/cgi/content/abstract/0508653103v1

Dembski's Blog sort of responds to the evidence that natural selection can
drive reproductive isolation.
http://www.uncommondescent.com/index.php/archives/864

I posted to Dembski's blog, but rarely does he allow my comments to appear.

Not only did he leave the comment, he responded to it, but in a
sarcastic manner dismissive and disrepectful of the actual evidence. He
Just Doesn't Get that what's important about this study: as a positive,
it shows that his conclusions are wrong; second, as a negative, it fails
to overturn or invalidate any basic evolutionary principles.

For Dembski to jeer that "you guys have got to get it straight:
why is this so important if evolution is as well-estabsilshed as
gravity?" is sheer childishness. Gravity Studies are still serious
business, after all: and we have a clearer picture of why evolution
happens at scale than we do gravity.

And we haven't stopped studying gravity either.

Dembski is just a whiner.

Another two years and he will go back to being an obscure nobody.

Stuart

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Dembskis Blog responds (sort of)
    ... Dembski's Blog sort of responds to the evidence that natural selection can ... drive reproductive isolation. ... Gravity Studies are still serious ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Dembskis Blog responds (sort of)
    ... Dembski's Blog sort of responds to the evidence that natural selection can ... drive reproductive isolation. ... Elf, I like to point out Dembski's nonsense as much as anyone, but I ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: BBC the creationist at the museum
    ... and evidence) into what the Bible says, then he has said that the ... Genesis 1-3 is the model that this scientific data fits ... affect matter as well (and our understanding of gravity has led=3D20 ... directly to the discovery of new kinds of matter and energy), ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Atheists are the biggest fools on Earth
    ... At least there is scientific evidence for the Big Bang. ... The evidence that this universe and life in it couldn't have ... Let's take gravity for a start. ... If I reach into a vase full of marbles, and pull out a red marble, am I ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: AIG strategy of "interpetation"
    ... scientific "proof" to establish the scientific case for creationism. ... the evidence is out there; yet what is at the core of the debate ... based on presuppositions that an individual has. ... Newtonian gravity and General relativity. ...
    (talk.origins)