Re: Why don't mitochondria have junk DNA?

rev.goetz wrote:

> John Harshman wrote:
>
>>rev.goetz wrote:
>>
>>
>>>John Harshman wrote:
>>>
>>>
>>>>Selection for fast replication? That's the usual idea for bacteria, but
>>>>do mitochondria have to replicate that often compared to the nucleus of
>>>>the same cell? That would depend on the lifetime of a mitochondrion and
>>>>its standing population in the cell. I'll have to look that up.
>>>>
>>>>If not that, then what?
>>>>
>>>>There are mitochondria with junk. In fact the control region has been
>>>>duplicated several times in different groups of birds, and one of the
>>>>copies is clearly non-functional. So it does happen. But why so rarely?
>>>
>>>
>>>Junk DNA is an extavagant byproduct of evolutionary processes because
>>>the rate of neutral mutational insertions from various types of
>>>repeated sequences appears to be significantly more frequent than the
>>>fixation rate of all mutational deletions. And I recall that only
>>>diploid cells have the mechanisms that generate various types of
>>>repeated sequences. (I do not have the time to look up the reasons for
>>>this.)
>>
>>You would seem to be talking about unequal crossing over. That's only
>>one of a host of processes that generate new sequences.
>
> Unequal crossing over is only one of a few mechanisms that help to
> generate non-coding DNA in eukaryotes.

It's the only one I know of that relies on diploidy.

>>>Concerning some junk DNA in mitochondria, this could have occurred by
>>>DNA transfer from the nuclear genome to the mitochondrial genome. I am
>>>not sure if I have heard of cases of DNA transfer from the nuclear
>>>genome to the mitochondrial genome, but I know that I heard of several
>>>examples of gene transfer from the mitochondrial genome to the the
>>>nuclear genome. So I would not be surprised to see if the reverse ever
>>>happened.
>>
>>I don't know of any such case. Like I said, the only mt junk I know of
>>involves a duplication of a mitochondrial region.
>
> I missed that you said it was a duplication of a mitochondrial region,
> so scratch what I said about DNA transfer from the nuclear genome to
> the mitochondrial genome.
>
> In general, mutational insertions/duplications are more likely to occur
> in eukaryotes compared to prokaryotes. And as someone said earlier in
> this topic, many eukaryotes are not harmed by an accumulation of DNA in
> the genome. So many insertions/duplications are neutral in terms of
> fitness in many eukaryotes, but in many prokaryotes a large increase in
> genome size causes a decrease in fitness. So natural selection prevents
> a large increase of "useless DNA"in many prokaryotes.

As I theorized at the outset. But can this possibly apply to
mitochondria? Larry's mechanism obviously can't, since mt genomes are
tiny by comparison with bacterial genomes. The other suggested
mechanism, selection for speedy replication, also would seem not to be
that strong in mitochondria, though that would depend on their
population genetics. I really have to dig this up and read it again:
Birky, C. W., Jr. 1991. Evolution and population genetics of organelle
genes: Mechanisms and models. Pages 112-134 In R. K. Selander, A. G.
Clark and T. S. Whittam (eds), Evolution at the Molecular Level. Sinauer
Assoc., Sunderland, MA.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Why dont mitochondria have junk DNA?
    ... >> the nuclear genome. ... > There is no such DNA in the typical mitochondrion. ... Plant mitochondria vary a lot in size ... "similar pattern of convergence with a gene sized chunk of nonconserved ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Why dont mitochondria have junk DNA?
    ... >>>There are mitochondria with junk. ... generate non-coding DNA in eukaryotes. ... >> DNA transfer from the nuclear genome to the mitochondrial genome. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Humans, chimps, wheat and frogs
    ... Depends on what part of the genome you're looking at. ... conserved) sequences are a tiny minority of the genome, ... These stretches of DNA ... As the species specific miRNAs described here are ...
    (talk.origins)
  • News: Junk DNA proves functional
    ... 'Junk' DNA proves functional ... In a paper published in Genome Research on Nov. 4, ... Institute of Singapore (GIS) report that what was previously believed to be ... other genes, bind specific repeat elements. ...
    (sci.bio.evolution)
  • Gene device slashes the cost of decoding
    ... A new kind of machine for decoding DNA may help bring costs so low that it ... computer that reconstructs the sequence of the genome. ... The decoding or sequencing of genomes has long depended on a chemical ... The machine's limitation is that at present it can only read DNA fragments ...
    (soc.culture.malaysia)