Re: Fraud in the CPI


"Rumpelstiltskin" <PleaseDoNotReplyByEmail@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:pjl5l35p60ok14cue3n1vqrlphtsce3rab@xxxxxxxxxx
On Sun, 2 Dec 2007 08:09:13 -0600, "John Galt"
<whoisjohngalt@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:


"Rumpelstiltskin" <PleaseDoNotReplyByEmail@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:n6d5l3p1tafejg7fqn1qporb94foc7cu78@xxxxxxxxxx
On Sun, 2 Dec 2007 07:07:56 -0600, "John Galt"
<whoisjohngalt@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

<snip>


A rigid, no-subs policy obviously results in a higher CPI, which is
obviously good for SS receipients. However, it doesn't accurately model
the
inflation in the economy.


If it "obviously" results in higher CPI, doesn't that
mean that the current situation is "obviously"
understated? Unbiased substitutions shouldn't
all trend the same way if they're really unbiased.

No. The objective is to accurately model inflation in the economy. This is
not a simple task, economists disagree on how best to do this, and
further,
opinions on the matter evolve as the art of economics becomes more
advanced,
economists advance new and better ideas as to how to do it, etc.



If "the economy" doesn't mean the welfare of people,
it doesn't really mean anything of much note, IMV.

The economy is the function of a country's business environment. "Welfare of
the people" is related in that people depend on that economy for their
livlihoods.

Some
things are claimed to be complicated even in their
everyday ramifications only because some persuasions
want to fog up reality, IMV. Of course, I am a "liberal".

"Reality" is subjective.

I do buy frozen ground beef, but right now "steak"
is on my shopping list for the next trip to Costco but
hamburger isn't, even though I still have some of
both in my freezer.

Maybe we should have a pet-food index, counting
the number of people who are living on pet food
because it's cheaper, today versus ten years ago.
(I've never known anybody who does live on pet
food, but I'm assured by urban-legendists that there
are some.)

Well, I'm sure their legends are .... urban.


Maybe so. I sure do hear a lot about people eating
pet food, but it might be like the welfare queens
driving Cadillacs, at least new ones rather than
wrecks - far more common in legend than in reality.

I'd think. The US has the richest poor people in the world, pretty much.
After all, the biggest dietary problems amongst the US poor are .....
obesity and its attendant diabetes.

JG





.

Relevant Pages

  • forget the mexicans, the terrorists, high gas prices, hillary, obama...Here are the REAL ISSUES WE A
    ... Inflation, Dow 13K and the Second Great Depression ... The problem is that college tuition costs have been rising ... booming economy providing well paying jobs upon graduation, ... American manufacturing, ...
    (soc.senior.issues)
  • Re: US Using Inflation To Reduce Its Debt.
    ... can't repay it's debt - it lets inflation take care of it. ... global economy readjusting to the US's period of trade deficits. ... There is something referred to in aviation as PIO - Pilot ... The natural reaction of the plane is to nose ...
    (soc.culture.china)
  • Tricky times for central bankers
    ... both inflation and recession, being a central banker is harder than it used ... economy from overheating. ... There are similar worries in Britain, whose central bank cut ...
    (soc.culture.african.american)
  • Re: US Using Inflation To Reduce Its Debt.
    ... can't repay it's debt - it lets inflation take care of it. ... global economy readjusting to the US's period of trade deficits. ... There is something referred to in aviation as PIO - Pilot ... The natural reaction of the plane is to nose ...
    (soc.culture.china)
  • America Reversal of Fortune
    ... When the American economy enters a downturn, ... Housing prices have fallen ... this year the federal government announced the second-largest ... inflation, just as standard prescriptions call for lowering interest ...
    (soc.culture.cuba)