Re: before katrina


"Islander" <nospam@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:9bednfHGk-SZNGTZnZ2dnUVZ_v6dnZ2d@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Rita wrote:

On Sat, 2 Sep 2006 04:56:27 -1000, "Alvin E. Toda" <aet@xxxxxxxx>
wrote:


On Fri, 1 Sep 2006, Jerry Okamura wrote:


"Alvin E. Toda" <aet@xxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:Pine.BSI.4.61.0609010624230.27474@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

On Fri, 1 Sep 2006, Jerry Okamura wrote:


"Alvin E. Toda" <aet@xxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:Pine.BSI.4.61.0608310654420.12929@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

No. They can enforce the order [to evacuate] at a local level. The
police should have come in afterwards and picked up the deadheads.

Well, yes, they "can" enforce the order, but the fact is they do not
enforce the order. So, what significance is it to say that they "can"
enforce the order at the local level? Besides, I thought you just
said in another part of this thread that was a federal
responsibility....care to explain what I see as an inconsistency in
the two statements?

The Feds need to pick up the stragglers. The police needs to take out
the refuseniks. Isn't that clear?

If the "police" takes out the refuseniks, are there going to be any
"stragglers"? And "if" there are any stragglers, which federal agency
should pick up the "stragglers"?

Jerry, it's up to the police to tell the difference. Obviously, you
can't.


No government was prepared to remove everyone from the city. These
folks discuss that:
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/117/5/S2/S396
The scene at the Superdome was planned as I read the above.

And that is the basic problem, i.e. no one is prepared to even have
plans to remove everyone from the city. The Superdome is not my idea
of evacuating a city.

The feds took too long to respond to evacuate the dome.

The "fed"? Who put them there in the first place.

Bad planning, but the best under the circumstances. The feds didn't
respond here. That's the problem.


The real problem is that when the Mayor gives the mandatory order
that late, then it is difficult for other agencies to act. But if
they are prepared, then the evacuation can still happen. Many left
prior to the order. The stragglers could still have been moved if the
feds were prepared.

Okay, then "if" the Mayor gave the mandatory evacuation order too late,
then it was his fault and not the fault of the federal government that
people had "difficulty" getting out of Dodge and "other" agencies to
act, which includes the federal goverment agencies? Again, which
federal agency do you propose "should have" forced these people out of
New Orleans?

Not necessarily. People still did evacuate without the order. Again the
feds move the stragglers, the cops remove the refuseniks.


Come on, you cannot be serious. We have all seen where state
government has issue so-called "mandatory evacuation orders" where
some choose to ignore those orders. But I would agre with the
statement that "if" they give a mandatory order to late, then
obviously not everyone is going to be able to get out of Dodge. You
keep blaming the feds, what about all those school buses we all saw on
TV, up to the hub caps in water, still sitting in the parking areas?
Are you saying that was a federal responsibility?

No the mayor gave the mandatory order. Those who could walk to the dome
did so. Those that could not, soon found themselves in the next couple
days dead or isolated on their roofs. The feds were the only ones who
could bring in busses to move the people in the dome-- and Brownie took
his own sweet time in doing so.

Staying the the city is not evacuating....why do you have such a
difficult time understanding that basic concept.

No. Walking to the Dome is in the plan for those who can walk but can't
drive. What's so difficult about that concept?


And there were those who couldn't walk to the Dome, elderly,
infirm, people with very young children who later were rescued
(or not) from their homes where they had taken to the top
floor or to the roof. Do you remember the searches of homes
where those with dead bodies were marked with the number
of dead and those with none were marked "clear"?

The fact is that most middle class people with the transportation
and the financial means got out. Some had neither of these.

It was a disaster of major scale and local resources failed. I don't
see that as being unusual given the circumstances. Outside help
took too long to arrive -- that is a fact and disputing it is just
plain silly. I think many of us put ourselves in the place of those
who were stranded, and we thought "there but for the grace of
God go I."

Even Bush says the government reponse failed the people. What
more does Jerry want?

Shields and Brooks on the Lerher Report last night had an interesting
discussion about what might have been the major failure of Katrina. David
Brooks, normally an apologist for the Bush administration, noted that
Katrina presented an opportunity to launch a major new initiative to
reduce poverty, a major reason for the scope of the disaster, IMV. Now, a
year later, there is no evidence of any new ideas on this.

Here is the text of what he said:

DAVID BROOKS: He had to do it. [referring to the reason for Bush's visit
to the region] He spent $120 billion, or at least committed $120 billion.
They want to talk about it. I think to me the biggest disappointment, not
primarily to blame the president -- I blame the Congress -- was that this
was a moment for an experiment, a whole series of social experiments,
because the slate was wiped clean, so let's see what we can do to try to
create anti-poverty programs. And that has been totally undone, not done.

There's been some aid that will be specific to New Orleans and to the
region, but as far as trying to re-imagine what you can do about poverty,
that never happened.

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/politics/july-dec06/sb_09-01.html

Don't you think if there was a solution to the perceived problem, that there
would not be a problem at all? It is a problem, it seems to me, because we
have not been abot to figure out how to solve the problem.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: before katrina
    ... The police should have come in afterwards and picked up the ... Well, yes, they "can" enforce the order, but the fact is they do ... The feds took too long to respond to evacuate the dome. ... then "if" the Mayor gave the mandatory evacuation order too ...
    (soc.retirement)
  • Re: before katrina
    ... police should have come in afterwards and picked up the deadheads. ... Well, yes, they "can" enforce the order, but the fact is they do not ... The feds took too long to respond to evacuate the dome. ... then "if" the Mayor gave the mandatory evacuation order too ...
    (soc.retirement)
  • Re: before katrina
    ... The police should have come in ... The Feds need to pick up the stragglers. ... then the evacuation can still happen. ... say, that is "if" they issue a mandatory evacuation order, that it is ...
    (soc.retirement)
  • Re: before katrina
    ... The police should have come in afterwards and picked up the deadheads. ... The Feds need to pick up the stragglers. ... The feds took too long to respond to evacuate the dome. ... then the evacuation can still happen. ...
    (soc.retirement)
  • Re: before katrina
    ... The police should have come in ... The Feds need to pick up the stragglers. ... then the evacuation can still happen. ... then "if" the Mayor gave the mandatory ...
    (soc.retirement)