Re: Long article on the dollar -- but worth reading

Rumpelstiltskin wrote:

I was thinking of gold as a metaphor for genuine value, and have no objection to what you point out as the shortcomings of
non-metaphoric gold in our own age. One of our problems is,
I guess, that we don't have anything as rock-firm to represent
true wealth nowadays. I guess wampum is out: an 8-year-old child in India can turn out a ton of it in just one 18-hour day
nowadays, as long as she maintains constant diligence all day.

I know nothing about Paul except for this article. Gold is an
artificial standard, and pretty soon will be obsolete as a standard
once we achieve the alchemist's dream of making it out of other
elements at reasonable cost. Since we don't have anything simple nowadays that generally represents wealth, we have the
problem of it being all too easy to sink in to irresponsibility, while postponing and thereby amplifying a reckoning, as we are doing in the US today and have done at other times in history. The famous black tulips of Holland come to mind, when people who thought they were wealthy were ruined overnight, because
the general population got out of bed one morning and, due to
Saturn having come into unfavourable aspect with Neptune, suddenly realized that these black tulips were just flowers and
not really worth what they had been said to be worth. We have
hundred-dollar bills instead of tulips, but they're really just paper,
not in themselves bread or internal combustion engines both of which have real worth but are unsuitable as currency for varying reasons. I'd better get out my astrological ephemerides
and check where Saturn is with relation to Neptune at the moment. I hope it's not about to move out of the House of Franklin.


This is a case when the lessons of history can be extremely valuable. Gold achieved popularity as a medium of exchange because it was relatively easy to detect forgery or counterfeiting. Indeed, counterfeit 'money' has been the bane of societies going back to pre-historic times.

Gold and other precious items used in past as media of exchange indeed possessed some variable intrinsic 'value', and were a physical representation of 'wealth', but that property was secondary to their primary function, which was as a medium of exchange. The problem is that one can't eat gold or silver, or wampum, or keep warm and dry with it, or in fact do anything of practical value with it. One can, however, trade the value the gold represents for varying amounts of food, or clothing, or housing.

The technological revolution of the past few decades has, in fact, rendered, in this country at any rate, the physical existence of a medium of exchange practically obsolete. I can count on the fingers of one hand the number of times I have physically paid for a commodity or service with 'money' out of my wallet in the past year or so. I receive statements from banks and brokers that contain written representations of amounts of "dollars", but they don't have the actual cash either.

The system is still in its infancy - the lack of a difficult to spoof identity system and identity theft are real problems that must be addressed - but my preferred medium of exchange is electronic bits and bytes, not gold or greenback dollars. Since I can use that electronic representation of 'wealth' to obtain food, clothing, and housing, or any of my other wants or needs, why should I care about the intrinsic value of any particular commodity?

All forms of money are merely a convenient metaphor. We are on our way towards a cashless society, and, barring a world-wide total collapse of modern society, I don't think it makes one bit of difference. I always get a giggle out of trying to visualize someone breaking off a chunk of a gold bar to trade for a loaf of bread.


--
Harlow
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Sci & Tech of Future Crime
    ... which compares gold with the other elements, antimatter, etc. ... as possible forms of uncopyable money. ... coconuts as money when no other suitable medium of exchange could be ...
    (rec.arts.sf.science)
  • Re: Long article on the dollar -- but worth reading
    ... true wealth nowadays. ... Gold achieved popularity as a medium of exchange because it was ... 'money' has been the bane of societies going back to pre-historic times. ... Gold and other precious items used in past as media of exchange indeed ...
    (soc.retirement)
  • Re: A first look at the Amero
    ... Foisting the Amero on on the residents of Turtle Island at an exchange ... It NEVER was backed by gold. ... accept gold or silver coin a tender in payment of debts. ... law, or law impairing the obligation of contracts, or grant any title ...
    (alt.gathering.rainbow)
  • Re: Alan Greenspans career as if it were one big comedy routine.
    ... Before he became chairman of the Fed, ... exchange should be durable. ... franc, etc.) differ from country to country, when all are defined in ... ...Under a gold standard, the amount of credit that an economy can ...
    (alt.gathering.rainbow)
  • Re: Survivalist Types
    ... becoming the local medium of exchange until a government is started. ... as gold, it doesn't rust or tarnish, 5000 year old gold is still gold, ... it and use it just like money. ... silver in exchange for a round. ...
    (misc.survivalism)