Re: Do angels throw with meteors?


Ed wrote:

The explanation that Mohammed gives is result of the fact that he was a
simple, superstitious man who told old wives tales.

We agree with you that the Messenger Muhammad salla Allah 'alayhi
wasallam was a simple man. Yet, he made a big nation -- something
that your sophisticated men cannot do. He was also given a book that
is studied by your academic figures; a book that wasn't revised once.

The wives of the Messenger (s) taught the saHaaba, the companions of
the Messenger (s). These women were shining in knowledge when your
women used to be used for filth. They were mujahideen who fought in
battles when your women were safer if they were doing nothing. We
advise you to read what Muslim historians wrote about your women.

Compared to Muslim women, our women are secured. Yours are not.
An example would be that our women inherited, while you inherited
the bodies of the women and what they owned. That person you are
mocking is the person who made you change these standards.

Much like the
German pagans of old who saw lightning and heard thunder and told
eachother that it was Thor (or Donar) who hit with his hammer on the
clouds.

There is no comparison simply because imagining how angels look like
is not permissable. As for jinn, they simply cannot be seen in their
original
form. There are no hammers, or throwing with "hands."

You should in fact go the opposite way. You should in fact start to
doubt the Quran very much now because the Quran looks so much like that
hadith.

That's what you wish. But you didn't do a good job to make me doubt.
I assume you would be happy to see every Muslim be a polytheists than
a believer.

Anyway, you didn't present a good case. Try again.

And because it was recited by Mohammed, we can safely conclude
that Mohammed made his superstition a part of the Quran. The Quran
contains old wive tales.

But you must admit that the Quran makes you busy. It gets your
attention.
What you wont admit is:

5:68. [...] Verily, that which has been sent down to you (Muhammad SAW)
from your Lord increases in many of them their obstinate rebellion and
disbelief. [...]

... but we can see it.

Abdalla Alothman

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Quran Only
    ... Universal Messenger) as a bearer of good news and as a Warner, ... my point was to understand these verses from the Book of Allah as I ... people who understand the Quran at a much deeper level than most others. ... rationalisation of their desires and fantasies have interpreted ...
    (soc.religion.islam)
  • Re: The Corruption of the Injil.
    ... Those who feel the injeel is not the Gospel ... > revealing to Mary birth of a Son -- between the Quran and the Gospel ... He it is Who sent among the unlettered ones a Messenger ...
    (soc.religion.islam)
  • Re: Muhammad in the Bible?
    ... talents were not present with the Messenger. ... Same argument can be raised against the Quran. ... which the traditions arrived apply to the Quran. ... So using "from," is a mistake and cannot be applied on iktatabaha, ...
    (soc.religion.islam)
  • Re: The origin of science
    ... About your objection about the Hadith. ... but the Quran has a clear statement about righetousness as ... that your messenger is indeed a messenger, ... This is a web site for Mathematics, ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Do angels throw with meteors?
    ... because it might be too slippery to maintain a sick sense of humor ... It is not important what he Quran says. ... superstitious man who told old wives tales. ... that Mohammed made his superstition a part of the Quran. ...
    (soc.religion.islam)