Re: why did Hitler Kill jews ?

"Stephen Graham" <grahams@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:drtvsn$5ec$1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Jim-Poncin wrote:
"Stephen Graham" <grahams@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:drripr$f00$1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
It's Focal Point Publications, which is essentially David Irving. Are you
aware of recent issues regarding Mr Irving's scholarship, particularly
regarding the Holocaust?

So, where are the examples of articles from that website that have been
found to be altered from the original?
Are there none?

So, no actual answer as to why we should trust that site rather than going
to the original source.

Are you going to double check everything you find reprinted on every
website.



Irving's work is now a tainted source which by academic standards is no
longer trustworthy and must be reverified.

So why are you making a big point of this?


The NSA report author dealt mostly with the communications intercepts,
plus some background. He raised issues as to why no follow-up was done
(anti-Semitism) on the info without going into what that follow-up might
have been.

You should have noticed that I have already said several times in this
thread what the issue is. The following are MY words, not the NSA report
author's.

Are you familiar with the Historian's Fallacy?

That's what you're doing: reinterpreting the actions of historial
individuals based on information they did not know at the time.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: why did Hitler Kill jews ?
    ... where are the examples of articles from that website that have been found to be altered from the original? ... no actual answer as to why we should trust that site rather than going to the original source. ... The NSA report author dealt mostly with the communications intercepts, ... He raised issues as to why no follow-up was done on the info without going into what that follow-up might have been. ...
    (soc.history.war.world-war-ii)
  • Re: Can someone help me?
    ... A follow-up - I found this thread which is full of info.... ... > There is a website called fastsearc.cc that has somehow ... > changes back to this fastsearch site. ...
    (microsoft.public.win2000.security)
  • Re: Website announce: Indices to Nearside LPODs - 2004 to 6-1-2006
    ... To follow-up on my 6-4-2006 website announcement. ... Updated this website to include an index to LPODs ... Only those LPOD articles with an ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)