Re: Feudalism

erilar <drache@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx > wrote:

In article <466e9e42$0$285$dbd4d001@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
"Peter Alaca" <p.alaca@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

johansson <1732johansson@xxxxxxxxx > wrote:

[exessive crossposting restricted to shm
and top posting corrected]

Thanks, Peter!

As if he should have learnt from past discussions not to show
off.... (more at the bottom)/Inger E

Look who's talking!
Oh, we have to hear from fake scholars, too, it seems.

Paul's assumption contradicted by every known scholar of History who
teaches (!) history from Medieval Age up to Modern Age. The
Feudalism is as a word only overshaddowed by 19th century's '-ism'
groupations. Difference which Paul seem to forgotten is that
Feudalism wasn't so much a political view but a way to organize the
agriculture sector's production in a way that the food could be
distributed to the growing towns merchandisers. That Paul, of
course, can't read French and thus didn't read Jacques Le Goff's
"L'Europe est-elle née au moyen âge? " from 2003 can't excuse his
ignorance since it's been translated into English "The birth of
Europe " 2005..... That he missed many other scholars show lack of
doing his homework.

So why then blaming Paul for not reading the French original?
Did you? I don't think so, because your French is lousy.
And did you also read Marc Blochs 'La société Féodale'?
I did, because I have an English translation.

I meant 'I didn't, because I have an English translation'

And did you learn anything new on the subject since you were
at school, followed more recent discussions?

I would venture to suggest that she doesn't actually read much of
anything serious, judging from the fairy tales she espouses as "fact".

Not much of a venture, I think.

--
p.a.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Feudalism
    ... Difference which Paul seem to forgotten is that Feudalism wasn't so ... So why than blaming Paul for not reading the French original? ... because I have an English translation. ...
    (soc.history.medieval)
  • Re: Feudalism
    ... teaches history from Medieval Age up to Modern Age. ... Difference which Paul seem to forgotten is that Feudalism wasn't so ... because your French is lousey. ... because I have an English translation. ...
    (soc.history.medieval)
  • French fear cover-up over babies bodies
    ... The French government is desperately attempting to quell fears that macabre medical experiments are being carried out in the ... Mr Bertrand was clearly shocked when he announced that some of the "pieces" preserved at Saint Vincent de Paul were 25 years old. ... The secretary general of Paris hospitals, Jean-Marc Boulanger, claimed only five people had access to the chamber containing the ...
    (soc.men)
  • Re: The Apprentice, what a bunch of cretins
    ... The mock-up burner was clearly never going to work properly - ... scouse woman who showed Paul up for the buffoon that he actually is. ... That there is no British cheese in French ... It was very telling the comments the posh bird made about Adam. ...
    (uk.media.tv.misc)
  • Re: The Apprentice, what a bunch of cretins
    ... That's the third time now where Paul has almost looked as though ... The mock-up burner was clearly never going to work properly - ... That there is no British cheese in French ... off together leaving Adam and Kristina, to try and sell when they ...
    (uk.media.tv.misc)
Loading