Re: Is Zionism Racism, or Is It Not?

SteveT wrote: 
On 19 Aug 2005 01:37:03 -0700, "Terry Cross" <tcross77@xxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:


roger_pearse@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:

Terry Cross wrote:

øéòéï áøúåïý/Riain Barton wrote:

Zionism is not racism.

All Zionism does is state that the land of Israel should be the Jewish
homeland. It is not racist to believe that an ethnic group has the right
to their own homeland.


To believe anything unique about any identifiable ethinic group is
racism.  You may not like it, but that is the current use of the
English world.

If a person announced that Anglo-Saxons have a unique right England,
that French people have a unique birthright to France, or that - horror
of horrors - that Germany is for Germans, they would be universally
denounced as racists (except by other racists, or course, who might
agree with them).


No doubt they would be so denounced.  This why accusing people of
racism is a hate-crime.


This is nonsense.  Please cite sources and law codes.


Of course British people have a right to
Britain, French to France, Germans to Germany, etc.  To assert
otherwise is hateful.


Ack!  "Germany for Germans" was one of the most hateful cries of the
Nazi era.  What is wrong with your sense of history?

TCross 

I don't think anybody had a problem with "Germany for Germans", & if
they'd stayed IN Germany there never would have been any difficulty.


	And if those jewish Poles had stayed out of Palestine ...

--
10 August 2005: US death rate in Iraq is 4.4 per day.
	-- The Iron Webmaster, 3499
 nizkor http://www.giwersworld.org/nizkook/nizkook.phtml
 Lawful to bomb Israelis http://www.giwersworld.org/israel/bombings.phtml a11
.

Relevant Pages