Re: clan of Vimara Peres

On Jun 14, 8:24 am, "M.Sjostrom" <q...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
again these genealogical fancies (aunt, great-aunt, grandmother) are built on very uncertain allegations of kinship:

queen Ximena, wife of Alfonso III, was not necessarily daughter of king Gartzia Ihttp://genealogics.org/getperson.php?personID=I00120397&tree=LEO

Oneka potentate in Portugal was not necessarily daughter of king Gartzia Ihttp://genealogics.org/getperson.php?personID=I00551252&tree=LEO

It's very unsubstantiated to build things on their postulated sisterhood.

----------------------

some days ago, Francisco uttered:
"...This Diogo Fernandez was a castilian magnate, never mentioned as count
and never "owner" of Guimarães."

I wonder why Diogo is made a Castilian by francisco, when we know that Diogo's brother, count Ero Fernandes, flourished in Galicia, such as Lugo. Diogo Fernandes became prominent in the valley of Minho and therearound. It would rather be more plausible to think that these brothers were regional nobles of Galicia-Portucale.


More speculation. It is generally agreed that Ero and Diego were
brothers, because they were active in the same region and had the same
patronymic. It is not documented that they were, so it could have
been coincidence.

taf
.