Re: Questions regarding different genealogical societies

Like other people have stated on these threads, you'd have to carefully
research the society you want to join, because, depending on the admission
standards, some gateway ancestors published in, say, RD 600, wouldn't make
the cut because they rely on secondary sources to make certain genealogical
connections and therefore wouldn't be accepted.

Kate

On Thu, Oct 2, 2008 at 6:15 AM, Kathy <kathysmi@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

As I've said before, am a fairly new researcher and came across a
website with a number of different genealogical societies listed. One
that would pertain to the medieval times would be The Order of the
Crown of Charlamagne in the United States. Upon looking at the
requirements for memberships, it says:

"Ladies and gentlemen are eligible for membership if they can prove
beyond doubt their descent from the Emperor Charlemagne. However,
they must be proposed in writing by two members or approved by the
Admission Committee of the Order to whom they are known personally.
Letters of proposal and endorsement are sent to the Registrar General,
who, with the approval of the Admission Committee, will invite the
prospect to become a member."

http://www.charlemagne.org/krslmem.html


From reading a number of your posts in here, my first thought was,
you can't prove it beyond a doubt, am I correct in that assumption.
Wouldn't it depend on how records were kept in that time period, and
that far back who is to say they were accurately taken, or transcribed
correctly? How can one prove beyond a reasonable doubt, full lines
and lineages that far back, isn't there always someone who will doubt
that research?

Another question is do all societies require a notarized copy of your
lineage report? Am just curious. I know that in time I'd like to
become more involved in the genealogy world, and hope to really "dig
in" so to speak, but at this point in my life I don't have the funds
to join all the different societies, and frankly at $550 usd a
membership, only the wealthy can in my eyes. Are there any that you
can join based on your lineage alone, rather than ones that will make
you go broke if your well off. Just curious.





-------------------------------
To unsubscribe from the list, please send an email to
GEN-MEDIEVAL-request@xxxxxxxxxxxx with the word 'unsubscribe' without the
quotes in the subject and the body of the message

.

Relevant Pages

  • Questions regarding different genealogical societies
    ... am a fairly new researcher and came across a ... "Ladies and gentlemen are eligible for membership if they can prove ... Another question is do all societies require a notarized copy of your ... can join based on your lineage alone, rather than ones that will make ...
    (soc.genealogy.medieval)
  • Re: Questions regarding different genealogical societies
    ... "Ladies and gentlemen are eligible for membership if they can prove ... Another question is do all societies require a notarized copy of your ... become more involved in the genealogy world, ... can join based on your lineage alone, rather than ones that will make ...
    (soc.genealogy.medieval)
  • Re: Questions regarding different genealogical societies
    ... Another question is do all societies require a notarized copy of your ... membership, only the wealthy can in my eyes. ... can join based on your lineage alone, rather than ones that will make ... fun events - here in NYC the Mayflower society hosts the Mayflower ...
    (soc.genealogy.medieval)
  • Re: Heljan plans for 2010 onwards
    ... There are a few societies that sometimes think would benefit from membership, but think its very important that I should be able to contribute as well as recieve info. Dont feel ready to contribute to some of better ones so not joined. ... Now understand just how good theyre models were at that time - fascinating. ... Nice idea, plant to do some of fiddly, time consuming, none critical jobs like making loco steps out of brass. ...
    (uk.rec.models.rail)
  • Re: How to cure the Illegal Alien Problem Let the Gov seize all their assets
    ... Not as far as Mensa knows either. ... membership, a society that exists only to sooth the raging ... intellectual societies, virtually all of which are invitation only. ... 1999 by the American Psychological Association ...
    (alt.politics)