Re: Ingeborg of Denmark


"M.Sjostrom" <qsj5@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:mailman.118.1207371325.16726.gen-medieval@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Peter Srewart: "...does not meet the criterion of
RATIONAL discourse..."


A clear point is that Peter Stewart's assessment of
what is rational and what is not, cannot be worth
anything; because evidently Peter Stewart suffers from
problematic mental instability, which makes him devoid
of capability to assess rationality, starting from
irrationality of his own reactions and behavior.

Rational means founded on reason, capable of being tested by reason. I hav
been asking a perfectly reasonable set of questions for days now, with no
reasonable anwer forhtcoming but rather a series of strawmen about denying
the existence of somone, and incredibly obtuse falsehoods about my position
more generally.

For the umpteenth time, what was your REASON for stating: "Volodar Glebovich
of Belarusia, ruler of Minsk and Polatsk, had sons, of whom two is attested
in Russian primary, near-contemporary evidence to have survived over
mid-1190s."?

What is your REASON for refusing to admit that this is untrue, that there is
no "Russian primary, near-contemporary evidence" attesting to two sons of
Volodar Glebovich living at any time, and that consequently you did not know
of any such proof for this relationship of father to sons when you posted
the misleading assertion?

Your attempts to patronise me and newsgroup members with whom I have been
communicating for years by musing inanely about my sanity will not dig you
out of this hole.

Peter Stewart


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Rationality is the bugaboo of the untamed mind
    ... He also fell into the trap of disparaging people who had ... and our inability to see where the borders between rationality ... That's sort of the point to rationalism, to reason. ... power to reason, yet they seemingly fail to apply it. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Ethical Relativism (Cultural Differences Argument)
    ... problem here is you introduce the "No true Scotsman" fallacy. ... So if, by definition, people who kill themselves for no good reason are ... God pre-ordained me to want to break the window. ... The question here is whether the concept of rationality should include ...
    (sci.logic)
  • Re: Return To Krondor Download
    ... Rationality is a particular manner ... One might also view the housing market as individual people reacting ... interest rates, government bailouts of losses from bad lending, perverse ... It is outside the scope of reason, ...
    (comp.sys.ibm.pc.games.rpg)
  • Re: 100 Years of Medical Robbery
    ... Are you in the habit of posting articles, ... David, all such articles are biased (ie. has some individual's ... >>some reason and rationality. ...
    (sci.med)
  • Re: god or no?
    ... You're found of rationality. ... a theory that reason is in itself a source of knowledge superior ... compare INTUITIONISM; contrasted with empiricism c: ...
    (misc.writing)
Loading