Re: Major new online resource: "Medieval Lands"

Peter Stewart wrote:
You don't need to be an expert in Hungarian genealogy to have the sense to
shut up about what you don't know.

I think you are still missing the point.

I am pointing out to you that when Charles Cawley speaks in his introduction
of a discovery concerning "the wives of Peter Orseolo King of Hungary", it
is clear that he is referring to the information he has found in Annalista
Saxo concerning Peter's second marriage, and not to the query about "Lui von
Frizberg" as you claimed. The text makes it clear that he sees the
information about Judith as an addition to the information in the volume
edited by Wegener (but written by Tyroller according to you), and as
providing extra chronological information about the first marriage.

You have pointed out that this is not in fact new, but that doesn't change
the facts that he clearly thought it was, and that this is what he was
referring to in the Introduction.

I really think you need to calm down, stop flinging around insults and
posting in capital letters, and try to be objective about all this.

Chris Phillips



.

Relevant Pages