Re: Eleanor Fitzalan and Thomas Browne

Will Johnson wrote:
<<
Probably not, see
<_http://www.medievalgenealogy.org.uk/cp/arundel.shtml_
(http://www.medievalgenealogy.org.uk/cp/arundel.shtml) >
Adrian >>

I'm confused by this reference to a new placement for Mary FitzAlan, wife
of
John, 4th Lord Strange of Blackmere

First it states that " Mary was a daughter of Edmund, the 9th earl, not
Richard, the 10th (see further details below). "

This would place Mary as a sister to Richard the 10th Earl

But then immediately below this it states that "Edmund, SON of Richard,
10th
earl of Arundel, had at least three daughters" [my emphasis] and then
gives
them and ADDS this Mary in that location.

I think this last part is a mistake. Mary should not be a daughter of
Edmund, son of Richard, but rather, an aunt to this Edmund, which would
match the
first statement and the remaining argument.

Sorry if the layout on that page is confusing. The first part, stating that
Mary was a daughter of Edmund, 9th earl, and that Edmund son of Richard had
at least three daughters, is meant to be a short summary of the corrections
to the quoted passage in CP, and then further details are given under
subheadings for these two points. So the three known daughters of Edmund son
of Richard are just Elizabeth, Philippa and Katherine - there's not meant to
be an implication that Mary was a fourth daughter.

Chris Phillips




.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Eleanor Fitzalan and Thomas Browne
    ... First it states that " Mary was a daughter of Edmund, the 9th earl, not ... This would place Mary as a sister to Richard the 10th Earl ... But then immediately below this it states that "Edmund, SON of Richard, 10th ...
    (soc.genealogy.medieval)
  • Re: Eleanor Fitzalan and Thomas Browne
    ... Mary was a daughter of Edmund, 9th earl, and that Edmund son of Richard had ...
    (soc.genealogy.medieval)
  • Re: "Nepotes" of Odo, bishop of Bayeux
    ... > William I and sister of Robert of Mortain, ... William the Conqueror through her mother - cf Orderic ... Chester, 'was son and heir of Richard, vicomte d'Avranches etc. in Normandy by Emma daughter of Herluin de Conteville and Herleve his wife, who was mother of William the Conqueror'. ...
    (soc.genealogy.medieval)
  • Re: More Stanley confusion ?
    ... If Eliz Brereton 'widow of Richard Cholmley' m.Randal Mainwaring of Over ... is found in a 2 Aug 1523 will for Sir Randall Brereton in which he bequeaths ... of his mother Elizabeth Brereton in 1523, ... of Morton-Corbet in Shropshire, by whom he had an only daughter Maud, ...
    (soc.genealogy.medieval)
  • Re: Supposed descents from Duke Richard III of Normandy
    ... daughter Papia married Walter de St Valery: ... Cawley states that Robert de Torigni described Papia as daughter of Richard ...
    (soc.genealogy.medieval)