Re: Parentage of Simon, duke of Lorraine (was Re: any children of Roger Hauteville..)
- From: "Peter Stewart" <p_m_stewart@xxxxxxx>
- Date: Wed, 28 Sep 2005 12:25:46 GMT
"John P. Ravilious" <therav3@xxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1127905984.373558.211010@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> Dear CEW, et al.,
>
> Thanks for that note concerning Bill Marshall's website (URL
> below).
>
> While only having a brief look, I have not noted any use of
> primary sources in the pedigrees I reviewed. I did note the following
> problem: Simon, duke of Lorraine (d. 1138/9) is shown as the son of
> Thierry/Diderick of Lorraine by his 2nd wife Gertrude of Flanders,
> which would make his wife Adelheid/Adelaide of Brabant his half-sister
> [1]. It is quite clear that Simon was the son of his father's first
> marriage to Hedwig von Formbach. See Leo's website, Genealogics, under
> the ID for Simon, duke of Lorraine (I00026284) [2]. There was also
> some extended discussion on SGM earlier this year [3].
Indeed - and just in case anyone picks up on this earlier thread at a
confusing point, it should be added that I was wrong at the start about
Simon's mother, following a strange error of Georges Poull in the second
edition of his (otherwise mostly excellent) work on the ducal family of
Lorraine. Maybe Bill Marshall has taken it from Poull too, and has not
caught up with the SGM discussion of this point.
Peter Stewart
.
- References:
- RE: any children of Roger Hauteville and Irene Angelina
- From: "Paul K Davis"
- Re: any children of Roger Hauteville and Irene Angelina
- From: CE Wood
- RE: any children of Roger Hauteville and Irene Angelina
- Prev by Date: Re: Robert Cheseman
- Next by Date: Re: 1st wife of Alan Fitz Roland of Galloway
- Previous by thread: Re: any children of Roger Hauteville and Irene Angelina
- Next by thread: Sir Robert Roos of Gedney (d. 1441) and his first wife, Joan de Rochford
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
