Mandela posse should take on Mugabe

In your dreams James ...... ever heard of solidarity?

--
James Kirchick: Mandela posse should take on Mugabe

The Examiner

Jul 20, 2007 3:00 AM (1 day ago)
by James Kirchick, The Examiner

WASHINGTON - On Tuesday, former President Jimmy Carter, retired Anglican
Archbishop Desmond Tutu, retired U.N. Secretary General Kofi Annan, former
President of Ireland Mary Robinson and Nelson Mandela, South Africa's first
democratically elected president, announced the launching of a promising new
initiative. Calling itself "The Elders," the group plans to tackle a host of
seemingly intractable global problems. Funding comes from Richard Branson,
the billionaire founder of Virgin Atlantic.

This posse of aging statesmen has yet to specify what will be on its agenda.
There is certainly no shortage of misery in the world for its to address,
but let humble me offer a modest proposal.

Over the past seven years, Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe has turned his
once prosperous country into a wasteland. Having stolen productive,
white-owned farms to award his political cronies, Mugabe now rules over a
country that depends on massive amounts of food aid, even though not long
ago Zimbabwe used to export grain and other staples. Millions are starving,
and it is estimated that a quarter of the population - over 3 million
people - have fled for neighboring countries, namely Mandela's homeland of
South Africa.

Is this not a worthy cause for The Elders, led by Mandela, to help
alleviate? After all, if this "diplomatic league of superheroes," as The New
York Times referred to them, cannot fix the problem, who can?

According to The Times, the initiative is Branson's idea, and its genesis
arose when he tried to arrange a meeting among Saddam Hussein, Mandela and
Annan in early 2003, in hopes that the latter two men might be able to
persuade the Butcher of Baghdad to relinquish power so as to forestall the
American-led invasion. This was a marvelous idea; had it proven successful,
it might have averted a war and its bloody aftermath.

A similar scenario would prove even more fitting for Zimbabwe. Mandela is
universally respected in Africa, more so than any statesman before him or
any in the future is ever likely to be. If Mandela were to use his fame and
popularity to call on his fellow African leaders and demand that Mugabe
resign, there is every reason to believe that the Zimbabwean dictator's
reign would be closer to an end.

To be fair, Mandela has criticized Mugabe before, but it was an isolated
incident. Seven years ago, as Mugabe's intimidation of political opposition
began to make headlines, Mandela said of African dictators generally, "The
public must bring these tyrants down themselves" and "pick up rifles." But
Mandela did not finger the Zimbabwean tyrant by name; when asked
specifically if he was referring to Mugabe, he replied, "Everybody here
knows who I am talking about. The situation exists in many parts of the
world, especially in Africa."

It seems that there are two entities one is best advised not to criticize:
God and Nelson Mandela. But Mandela's silence on the crimes being
perpetrated in the country next door do not just mar his legacy as one of
the 20th century's great historical figures, it betrays the values of human
rights and political freedom he embodies.

Speaking out on Mugabe's politically induced starvation, torture, harassment
of journalists and political opponents and other myriad offenses would cost
Mandela nothing. And there's no telling what sort of on-the-ground political
impact his castigation of a fellow liberation hero might have.
After retiring, Mandela apologized for his inaction on the AIDS crisis while
he was president. He still has time to avoid an apology over Zimbabwe.

Examiner columnist James Kirchick is assistant to the editor in chief of The
New Republic and reported from Zimbabwe last year.



.

Relevant Pages

  • Zimbabwe rejects Mandela rebuke
    ... Zimbabwe rejects Mandela rebuke ... former South African President Nelson Mandela. ... Southern African leaders have called on President Robert Mugabe to ...
    (soc.culture.zimbabwe)
  • Sadc ill-equipped to deal with rogue states
    ... Sadc ill-equipped to deal with rogue states ... to tackle the Zimbabwe crisis once and for all. ... the time as they did in Lusaka combating those against Mugabe. ... The DRC war created a major row between Mugabe and Mandela, ...
    (soc.culture.zimbabwe)
  • If only Zim had a Mandela
    ... 'If only Zim had a Mandela' ... Cape Town - If only Zimbabwe had a Nelson Mandela, ... country said on Monday in congratulating the former South African president ...
    (soc.culture.zimbabwe)