Re: Yuschenko's Ukraine blames Russia for Holodomor famine

seems well balanced

"kiril" <kirill@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:c9c1a$494fc58f$d1b7067c$28730@xxxxxxxxxxxx
Ukraine blames Russia for Holodomor famine

22/12/2008 16:08

MOSCOW. (RIA Novosti political commentator Pyotr Romanov)

Vitaly Churkin, Russia's Permanent Representative (Ambassador) to the
United Nations, said the Russian delegation had thwarted Ukraine's
attempts to persuade the UN General Assembly to examine and approve a
resolution on recognizing Holodomor, the 1932-1933 famine, or Hunger
Plague, that affected Soviet Ukraine and several other regions of the
U.S.S.R., as genocide of the Ukrainian nation.

The Ukrainian administration of President Viktor Yushchenko representing
one of the country's several political forces has been trying to
facilitate this resolution's approval for a long time.

Last year, Russia also managed to thwart Ukrainian diplomatic efforts to
persuade the 62nd UN General Assembly to discuss the Holodomor issue. In
despair, the Ukrainian delegation to the UN launched a
signature-collection campaign in support of a Holodomor declaration. This
motion was supported by 30 member-states, with another 160 voting against.

It appears that this issue will be raised again. In November 2006, the
Ukrainian Supreme Rada (Parliament) passed a law on Holodomor, recognizing
it as genocide against the Ukrainian nation.

Ukrainian authorities have investigated the Holodomor case and will submit
their findings to the national Supreme Court soon. Many analysts say Kiev
or Ukrainian citizens would have the right to file lawsuits with
applicable European courts after the Supreme Court examines the case.
Technically speaking, Russia, the legal successor of the Soviet Union,
would have to assume responsibility in case it fails to defend itself to
the EU court.

Doubtless, the 1932-1933 Holodomor is a terrible tragedy; and the memory
of its victims deserves every respect. I have read the speeches of
President Yushchenko and the law on Holodomor, and I agree with many
aspects.

However, I cannot agree when the discussion of Holodomor involves
time-serving political considerations and unsophisticated, albeit
bellicose radical Ukrainian nationalism. This mixture of sincere human
suffering, outright politicking and uneducated hostility is the most
deplorable aspect of the discussion.

But I don't doubt that Holodomor was caused by natural factors and the
Marxist-Leninist ideology, and that the Soviet Government used various
methods, including famine, to fight peasantry. However, this had nothing
to do with the Ukrainian nation's genocide.

If the Holodomor tragedy is removed from historical context, there are
some geographic and ideological questions. In reality, the terrible famine
of 1932-1933 was simply another episode in a grandiose peasant war,
sometimes called "Green Noise" by historians, including foreign
researchers.

I advise you to read "The Great Soviet Peasant War: Bolsheviks and
Peasants, 1917-1933" by Italian scholar Andrea Graziosi who calls those
events the greatest peasant war in European history, and with good reason.

However, that war began long before the October 1917 Bolshevik Revolution.
Graziosi says many of those who led the bloody 1918-1921 peasant revolts,
including Nestor Makhno (1888-1934) and Alexander Antonov (1888-1922), had
made a name for themselves during the First Russian Revolution of
1905-1907.

The Tsarist Government, rather than the Bolsheviks, had introduced the
food-surplus appropriation system at the beginning of World War I. The
Provisional Government simulated this strategy, with the Bolsheviks
introducing even tougher measures from 1918 through 1921 during the
Russian Civil War. However, Russian and Ukrainian peasants always resisted
food-supply squads under Nicholas II (1868-1818), Alexander Kerensky
(1881-1970) and the Red Commissars.

Although famines were not uncommon in the former Russian Empire, Ukraine
only remembers the tragedy of 1932-1933. However, the 1921 Russian famine
that affected mostly the Volga-Ural region was no less terrible. In the
early 1930s, famine spread to southern Belarus, the Volga Area, the
Central Black Soil Region, the Cossack regions of the Don and Cuban river
basins and the North Caucasus where it had begun in 1931. Northern
Kazakhstan, South Urals and West Siberia were also affected. West Ukraine,
then part of Poland, also experienced famine.

Such amnesia on the part of Ukrainian analysts hardly amounts to minor
discrepancies. It would be more logical to suspect them of deliberate and
selective forgetfulness.

The Soviet Government did take tough action to crush peasant revolts.
Famous Red Army commander Mikhail Tukhachevsky (1893-1937) who later
became Marshal of the Soviet Union used poison gas to suppress the Tambov
rebellion of 1919-1921. Although similar punitive tactics were used in
Russia and Ukraine, the Red Army did not fire poison-gas shells against
Ukrainian peasantry.

The Bolsheviks used famine as an instrument to persuade peasants to join
collective farms and to completely weaken their resolve but cared little
about their ethnic affiliation. The Ukrainians were not the only ones who
suffered under Soviet rule. This is nothing but ideological illiteracy.
The Bolsheviks and the Nazis perpetrated numerous crimes, albeit for
different reasons. The Nazis used racial discrimination as a rationale to
kill so-called sub-humans. This was real genocide. The Bolsheviks who
advocated internationalism killed enemies from other social strata.

Instead of blaming the Russian nation, Kiev ought to condemn Marxism and
Stalinism.

Although official documents, including the law on Holodomor, say nothing
about possible compensation from Russia, radical Ukrainian nationalists
are sure that the world will equate Holodomor with the Holocaust, and that
Moscow will reimburse Kiev.

Ukrainian nationalists believe that the descendants of those who survived
chemical attacks near Tambov must reimburse the descendants of Holodomor
survivors. In my opinion, this is the ultimate in cynicism.

On October 19, The Mirror of the Week, a Ukrainian online publication,
said: "Ukraine has repeatedly stated that it does not link the recognition
of Holodomor as genocide with the Russian Federation's responsibility
under international law and will not make any claims to it. However, this
does not rule out the right of private individuals, the descendants of
Holodomor victims, to file claims against the Russian Federation, which is
considered the legal successor of the U.S.S.R."

This amounts to political double standards. Ukrainian authorities would
distance themselves from private lawsuits which could be upheld. However,
such behavior is inconsistent with universal human values.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Yuschenkos Ukraine blames Russia for Holodomor famine
    ... Ukraine blames Russia for Holodomor famine ... The Ukrainian administration of President Viktor Yushchenko representing one of the country's several political forces has been trying to facilitate this resolution's approval for a long time. ... Graziosi says many of those who led the bloody 1918-1921 peasant revolts, including Nestor Makhno and Alexander Antonov, had made a name for themselves during the First Russian Revolution of 1905-1907. ...
    (soc.culture.russian)
  • The Ukrainian-Russian Cultural Conflict
    ... focused on the more well known: the status of the Russian language, ... language spoken by Ukrainians and their ... On April 1 President Yushchenko visited Gogol's museum in his native ... settled on what nation and state it was building. ...
    (soc.culture.ukrainian)
  • The Ukrainian-Russian Cultural Conflict
    ... focused on the more well known: the status of the Russian language, ... language spoken by Ukrainians and their ... On April 1 President Yushchenko visited Gogol's museum in his native ... settled on what nation and state it was building. ...
    (soc.culture.ukrainian)
  • Ukrainians need English, not Russian
    ... Ukrainians need English, not Russian ... language use in Ukraine shouldn't be overlooked: ... It would reinforce the notion that Ukrainian is only ...
    (soc.culture.ukrainian)
  • Russian language in retreat in Ukraine
    ... Russian language in retreat in Ukraine By MARA D. BELLABY, ... Today Ukrainian has emerged from second-class status, ... Russian-speaking east and south is the base of politicians who want to ...
    (soc.culture.ukrainian)
Loading