French Students Curious Over "`Eid Absence"

French Students Curious Over "`Eid Absence"

By Hadi Yahmid, IOL Correspondent

PARIS, January 13, 2006 (IslamOnline.net) - `Eid celebrations of Muslims
students in France and their school absence during the festival have raised
questions among their non-Muslim schoolmates on the nature of `Eid and the
accompanying celebrations and rituals during the occasion.

"Why our Muslim friends Mohamed, Amani and Omar are absent during `Eid?"
questioned some non-Muslim students.

Others wonder about the Muslim celebrations of `Eid and whether they have
"Saint Claus" celebrations similar to the one of non-Muslims.

"These questions are repeatedly asked by French students in schools,
institutes and kindergartens during the first two days of `Eid Al-Adha,"
IslamOnline.net Correspondent says.

The Muslim minority in France, along with other Muslims worldwide, has
celebrated `Eid Al-Adha Tuesday, January 10.

France has an estimated Muslim minority of six million, the largest Muslim
minority in Europe.

Festival

Many young students ask their teachers about reasons that make Muslim
students dump classes during the `Eid festival.

"We attempt to explain to French young children that `Eid Al-Adha is an
important festival for Muslims, during which all family members should meet
together," Beatrice Mlaire, a kindergarten teacher told IOL Friday, January
13.

"We also give a short definition on `Eid and the Muslim ritual of
sacrificing sheep, but without making it a topic of discussion, because it
is prohibited under French secularism."

A financially-able Muslim sacrifices a single sheep or goat or shares six
others in sacrificing a camel or cow as an act of worship during `Eid
Al-Adha.

The ritual reminds Muslims of the great act of sacrifice Prophet Ibrahim and
his son Isma`eel were willing to make for the sake of God.

"Ghost Places"

Schools which have a heavy attendance of Muslim students seemed like "ghost
places" during `Eid due to the absence of the Muslim students.

John Beatrice Omfer, a professor of French literature, said schools which
have heavy Muslim attendance were turned into "ghost places" during the
Muslim festival.

"Only eight out of 25 students showed up in classes in the first day of
`Eid," said Omfer, who teaches French literature in an institute in the city
of Montfrin.

"This is understandable, especially in the highly Muslim-populated areas."

Omfer, however, said that some non-Muslim schools took advantage of the
Muslim occasion and absent themselves from attending schools as well.

Two days before `Eid Al-Adha, the French education ministry urged schools to
avoid holding exams during the Muslim `Eid celebrations.

"Parents of Muslims students usually inform school headmasters that their
sons will be absent from attending classes during `Eid," Muslim activist
Mahraziya Ma'eza told IOL.

She stressed that the move helps cement ties between the French Muslims and
other members of French society.

"In some cases, we get messages from school masters and teachers wishing
French Muslims happy `Eid celebrations."

Debate

Absence of French Muslim students from attending schools during `Eid has
sparked a debate over making the Muslim festival an official holiday.

French TV channel LCI hosted a discussion attended by a group French Muslim
activists on declaring `Eid Al-Adha a national occasion.

But most of the callers objected to making the Muslim `Eid as a French
national day.

Late December 2003, French President Jacques Chirac dropped a suggestion for
making the Muslim `Eid Al-Adha and the Jewish Yom Kippur as state holidays
for Muslims and Jewish students respectively in government schools.

http://islamonline.net/English/News/2006-01/13/article05.shtml


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: French Students Curious Over "`Eid Absence"
    ... > French Students Curious Over "`Eid Absence" ... > Others wonder about the Muslim celebrations of `Eid and whether they have ...
    (soc.culture.pakistan)
  • Re: French Students Curious Over "`Eid Absence"
    ... >French Students Curious Over "`Eid Absence" ... Your President in finally advocating nuking of Muslim ... >Schools which have a heavy attendance of Muslim students seemed like "ghost ...
    (soc.culture.pakistan)
  • The crescent of fear
    ... fatwa, a nice fatwa, a fatwa to be proud of. ... French television news has led its morning and evening ... integration, poverty, unemployment, incipient French racism and so on. ... The political aspirations of many French Muslim ...
    (soc.culture.african.american)
  • Re: France Denies Citizenship to Muslim Woman in Full-Body Burqa
    ... A Muslim woman, who sheaths herself in a head-to-toe veil, is denied ... president of the National Federation of French ... Those Muslim "immigrants" have no intention of adapting to France, their intention is to replace France with their vision of the 13th century "heaven" that their Islam will usher in. ... Theodore Roosevelt on Immigrants and being an AMERICAN ...
    (soc.retirement)
  • Re: France Denies Citizenship to Muslim Woman in Full-Body Burqa
    ... A Muslim woman, who sheaths herself in a head-to-toe veil, is denied ... French citizenship because she hasn't assimilated enough into this ... president of the National Federation of French ... Council of State's ruling upholding immigration officials' refusal to ...
    (soc.retirement)