Israel of the Future



http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/08/12/AR2005081201546.html?referrer=email&referrer=email
Pullout Focuses Israel on Its Future
Dreams Overtaken By Demographics

By Scott Wilson
Washington Post Foreign Service
Saturday, August 13, 2005; Page A01

JERUSALEM, Aug. 12 -- As a young member of Israel's parliament in 1978,
Ehud Olmert had the opportunity to vote in favor of the historic Camp David
peace accords, which returned the Sinai Peninsula to Egypt and brought
Israel peace with its most powerful enemy. Olmert voted against it.

"I voted against Menachem Begin," Olmert, now Israel's finance minister,
said this week. "I told him it was a historic mistake, how dangerous it
would be, and so on and so on. Now I am sorry he is not alive for me to be
able to publicly recognize his wisdom and my mistake. He was right and I
was wrong. Thank God we pulled out of the Sinai."


Monday, August 15, at Noon ET
Controversial Gaza Pullout Begins Monday
Dr. Amiel Ungar, a lecturer at Judea and Samaria College Ariel and a
contributing editor of the Jerusalem report, discusses religious opposition
to the Israel's withdrawal from parts of the Gaza Strip and West Bank.


Monday, August 15, at 11 a.m. ET
Gaza Pullout Set to Begin Monday
David Makovsky, director of the Project on the Middle East Peace Process at
The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, discusses the Gaza pullout
and what it means for Arab-Israeli relations.


Graphic
Palestinian Hopes in Gaza
Palestinians in the Gaza Strip hope that their lives will improve once
Israel begins to evacuate 8,500 Jewish settlers on Monday. Palestinians
will then be able to move freely within the Gaza Strip, but will have to
pass through border crossing points to reach Israel for work or transit to
the West Bank. Other post-evacuation restrictions could continue to hamper
Gaza's economic development.


Monday, August 15, at 2 p.m. ET
Controversial Gaza Pullout Begins Monday
Lewis Roth, assistant executive director at Americans for Peace Now,
discusses support for Isreal's withdrawal from parts of the Gaza Strip and
West Bank.

In two days, the Israeli military will begin the first evacuation of Jewish
settlements since the Sinai pullout, abandoning 21 settlements in the Gaza
Strip and the network of military installations that protected them for
nearly four decades. This time, Israel will not receive anything in return
for the land it is leaving. Olmert has been one of the plan's most vocal
supporters.

The unilateral decision to leave Gaza, pushed for more than a year by Prime
Minister Ariel Sharon at great political expense, has left Israeli society
at odds over the future character and shape of the Jewish state.
http://media.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/graphic/2005/08/09/GR2005080900593.gif

After Israel captured the West Bank and Gaza in the 1967 Middle East war,
Israeli Jews moved to settle the newly occupied territories. From about
5,000 in the late 1960s, the number of Jewish settlers in the West Bank and
Gaza has grown to about 258,000 today, not including those who live in East
Jerusalem neighborhoods that Israel annexed following the war.

But over the past year or so, the dream of settling the territories has
collided with Israel's demographic challenge -- how to survive as a
democratic Jewish homeland -- convincing most Israelis that the state must
give up land to protect its Jewish majority. At the same time, the violent
Palestinian uprising that began in September 2000 was claiming thousands of
Israeli and Palestinian lives.

Sharon, an architect of the settler movement, has long supported the notion
of a Greater Israel stretching from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean
Sea. But he has scaled back those territorial ambitions. Even though
disengagement amounts to the first time outside the framework of peace
negotiations that Israel will withdraw from what many Jews consider part of
the Land of Israel described in the Bible, Sharon has cast it as a step
toward creating a state that has more defensible boundaries with fewer
Arabs inside them.

A recent poll conducted by Tel Aviv University showed that 57 percent of
Israelis support the plan, a majority that has remained relatively constant
throughout the tumultuous debate.

The same poll showed that 36 percent of the population opposes Sharon's
plan to evacuate Gaza and four small West Bank settlements. Many of the
opponents are from a younger generation, energized by a summer of protest,
who have become the foot soldiers of a more politically assertive religious
minority.

Whether the evacuation unfolds smoothly will probably determine Israel's
immediate course on matters of peace with the Palestinians, the role of
settlers in Israeli society and the outcome of general elections that must
be held by November 2006.

"If this is done properly, there are a lot of options open to us," said
Eyval Giladi, Sharon's director of strategic planning. "If we fail, there
will be a lot fewer."

A Demographic Race



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


For nearly 40 years, Gaza has proved to be a difficult place to defend and
an even harder one to leave. The government initially encouraged Israelis
to move into its dunes for strategic reasons -- to create a bulwark against
an Egyptian invasion and divide the Palestinian population. The settlers, a
mix of religious and economically motivated Israelis, developed farms and
greenhouses, staffed by cheap Palestinian labor.



------------------------------------------
In 1994, under the terms of the Oslo accords, Israel handed the
Palestinians political control over roughly 80 percent of Gaza's territory.
But the Israeli army and the Jewish settlements remained. Today, about
8,500 Jewish settlers live among 1.3 million Palestinians in Gaza, an
imbalance that has proved costly in lives and money to sustain.

Under international pressure to make progress toward peace, Sharon proposed
the unilateral withdrawal from Gaza in part to avoid negotiating with
Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat. After Arafat died in November, the
election of Mahmoud Abbas to succeed him as president of the Palestinian
Authority brought a cease-fire agreement with Israel.


Monday, August 15, at Noon ET
Controversial Gaza Pullout Begins Monday
Dr. Amiel Ungar, a lecturer at Judea and Samaria College Ariel and a
contributing editor of the Jerusalem report, discusses religious opposition
to the Israel's withdrawal from parts of the Gaza Strip and West Bank.


Monday, August 15, at 11 a.m. ET
Gaza Pullout Set to Begin Monday
David Makovsky, director of the Project on the Middle East Peace Process at
The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, discusses the Gaza pullout
and what it means for Arab-Israeli relations.


Graphic
Palestinian Hopes in Gaza
Palestinians in the Gaza Strip hope that their lives will improve once
Israel begins to evacuate 8,500 Jewish settlers on Monday. Palestinians
will then be able to move freely within the Gaza Strip, but will have to
pass through border crossing points to reach Israel for work or transit to
the West Bank. Other post-evacuation restrictions could continue to hamper
Gaza's economic development.


Monday, August 15, at 2 p.m. ET
Controversial Gaza Pullout Begins Monday
Lewis Roth, assistant executive director at Americans for Peace Now,
discusses support for Isreal's withdrawal from parts of the Gaza Strip and
West Bank.

But coordination remains tenuous, giving radical Palestinian groups such as
the Islamic Resistance Movement, known as Hamas, an opening to claim that
the Israeli withdrawal is a result of their rocket attacks and suicide
bombings. Hamas is sponsoring a contest for the best mural depicting the
Israeli evacuation as a victory for the group.

According to population projections, the number of Arabs living between the
Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea will surpass the number of Jewish
residents, who now total roughly 5.2 million, by the end of the decade.

Israeli political leaders worry that, unless a two-state solution to the
conflict can be reached by that point, the 3.5 million Arabs living under
Israeli military law in the West Bank and Gaza will give up the goal of
having their own nation. Instead, they could demand the right to vote
inside Israel, where 1.3 million Arab citizens already live, forcing
Israelis to choose between the state's Jewish character and democracy.

"Among the Israelis, there has been a shift in thinking," said Ali Jarbawi,
a Palestinian professor at Beir Zeit University near Ramallah. "Now,
instead of land for peace, it is land for time."

The key players in the demographic race could be seen here last week at the
Western Wall in Jerusalem's Old City, where more than 70,000 people
gathered to protest disengagement by chanting prayers of lamentation and
forgiveness. Young couples flooded into the plaza, pushing scores of baby
strollers. One religious settler held a baby in one arm and a prayer book
in the other, his M-4 rifle slung over his shoulder.

"The prime minister has changed and the situation has changed," said Shimon
Peres, the deputy prime minister, who has been Sharon's friend since the
two were active in Israel's pre-state security organizations. "Zionism was
built on geography, but it lives on demography."

As leader of the Labor Party, Peres joined Sharon's Likud-led government
largely to protect the disengagement plan. But the unusual political
alliance, built on generational rather than partisan lines, may shatter
once the election season begins after the evacuation.

"What to do next on the West Bank has been a silent discussion until now,"
Peres said. "Once we are out of Gaza, it will become an open debate, maybe
even the central debate in the next election."

Building a Coalition



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Amiel Ungar lives in the hilltop settlement of Tekoa in the southern West
Bank, in a stucco home where he moved 26 years ago from New York. He has
raised five sons there on the barren edge of the Judean Desert, the rocky
heart of what religious Zionists believe is the Promised Land.

Ungar, a lecturer at Ariel College in the West Bank, said religious
settlers like himself have played an important role in mainstream Israeli
life for years. They do obligatory military service, unlike members of the
ultra-Orthodox community, and are prominent in the army's professional
officers corps.


--------------------------------3----------------------
We simply won't be lectured to by people who preach democracy, but this
European-style democracy that believes it knows better than the people,"
said Ungar, 57.

Israel's religious Zionist movement holds a range of opinions on the terms
of any future peace agreement with the Palestinians. Ungar said the
movement's mainstream consensus is that the Palestinians should accept the
Israeli presence in the territories or else move to Jordan or Egypt.
Disengagement, he said, rewards Palestinian militancy.


Monday, August 15, at Noon ET
Controversial Gaza Pullout Begins Monday
Dr. Amiel Ungar, a lecturer at Judea and Samaria College Ariel and a
contributing editor of the Jerusalem report, discusses religious opposition
to the Israel's withdrawal from parts of the Gaza Strip and West Bank.


Monday, August 15, at 11 a.m. ET
Gaza Pullout Set to Begin Monday
David Makovsky, director of the Project on the Middle East Peace Process at
The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, discusses the Gaza pullout
and what it means for Arab-Israeli relations.


Graphic
Palestinian Hopes in Gaza
Palestinians in the Gaza Strip hope that their lives will improve once
Israel begins to evacuate 8,500 Jewish settlers on Monday. Palestinians
will then be able to move freely within the Gaza Strip, but will have to
pass through border crossing points to reach Israel for work or transit to
the West Bank. Other post-evacuation restrictions could continue to hamper
Gaza's economic development.


Monday, August 15, at 2 p.m. ET
Controversial Gaza Pullout Begins Monday
Lewis Roth, assistant executive director at Americans for Peace Now,
discusses support for Isreal's withdrawal from parts of the Gaza Strip and
West Bank.

Many Israelis believe the settlement movement is an obstacle to peace, an
impression reinforced during recent months of resistance to the evacuation
plan. Many secular Israelis, especially those on its coastal plain, argue
that the government created the problem by pampering the settlers for
years.

"They have long been the spoiled child in the family," said Kobi Niv, a
screenwriter and teacher at Tel Aviv University. "Now, suddenly, the father
-- and he's truly their father -- has said, 'Enough.' "

In the coming months, Ungar said, the religious Zionist movement will begin
building a new electoral coalition. It will reach out to disaffected Likud
members, residents of Israel's poorest cities, Russian immigrants and
secular war veterans who still believe in a Greater Israel.

"The entire generation, the boys and girls of summer 2005, are going to
demand a change," Ungar said. "The government has made a decision. A future
government may be able to rectify that decision."

The New Generation



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Many of those boys and girls have gathered in Neve Dekalim, the largest
settlement in Gaza. They have turned the community square into a kind of
joyless festival, a party counting down the end of the community.

The Palestinian "solution for peace is that we all should die," said Avivit
Partush, 24, who arrived from her home near Tel Aviv to join the
disengagement opponents. "There are many states where they can live. We are
surrounded by countries that are their countries."

Partush and a few friends, all of them religious, are running a nonprofit
snack bar from a derelict van. They have received donations to support the
holdouts and sell their sandwiches for less than 50 cents each. Hagai
Swisa, 25, left the Israeli army after five years because he would not
participate in the disengagement operation. Now, a week later, he is
helping feed the demonstrators after sneaking through the military cordon
around Gaza to get inside.

"We're willing to take one step more than our parents," Swisa said.

Just down the road, along a strip of beach behind a tall metal fence, are
the hard-core holdouts of Shiryat Hayam. Hundreds of settlers have gathered
there in recent weeks. The army predicts that it might be one of the few
places where the evacuation turns violent. It is easy to see why.

A group of children, some not even teenagers, stand at the gate into the
camp. They wave some cars through, tell others to turn around, even though
the Israeli soldier has given permission to pass.

"You can run them over for all I care," a harried Israeli soldier said one
recent afternoon.

"The soldier means nothing to us," one angry teenager inside the camp said.
"He has no authority here."

==================================end=======================



cheers
pluto
.



Relevant Pages

  • Breaking The Last Taboo - Gaza and the Threat of World War By John Pilger
    ... Breaking The Last Taboo - Gaza and the Threat of World War ... on the website of the Times of Israel were the words: ... An MP, Ayelet Shaked, whose party is a member of the governing coalition, calls for the extermination of Palestinian mothers to prevent them giving birth to what she calls "little snakes". ... the United States and its allies have been on a rampage. ...
    (soc.culture.jewish)
  • Audio/Transcript: Ali Abunimah vs Israeli ex-FM Ben-Ami
    ... I debated former Israeli foreign minister Shlomo Ben-Ami ... Fatah and Hamas agreed on a document to implicitly recognize Israel within ... We go to Gaza to speak with Palestinian physician Dr. Mona ...
    (soc.culture.israel)
  • Syjonazim
    ... Peace will need more than David Grossman - or Uri Avnery ... the same anguished values of Labor Zionism that won Israel ... and hide inside the few Palestinian villages inside Israel that had not ...
    (soc.culture.polish)
  • GAMLA on Gaza
    ... Egyptian Ambassador to Israel: ... Gaza since "there are enough weapons in Gaza as it is". ... Not a single Palestinian security officer was visible on the horizon. ...
    (soc.culture.israel)
  • Re: more jooze crap going down
    ... GAZA: Palestinian government worker Khaled Mohammad said he had nothing ... Israel presses an offensive in Gaza to free a soldier and halt rocket ... already dealing with a Western aid embargo that has left the Hamas ...
    (misc.survivalism)