Re: Let the Jews be delivered from their darkness!

On Apr 30, 9:52 am, flav...@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
On 30-Apr-2007, bac...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
In article <f13n00$j8...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, flav...@xxxxxxxxxxx writes:

On 29-Apr-2007, "Giorgies E. Geshahnna" <geshah...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Goyims are anti-Semitic by birth,
an inheritance from their grandfather Esav.

What?
This was a really stupid thing to say.

I see that you disparage the talmudic dictum "halacha hi b'yadua
she'esav sonei l'yisrael".

No, I don't.
I disparage his & your interpretation of it.

Fair enough. So what is *your* interpretation of this dictum of Hazal.
Please base your interpretation on sources actually found in Hazal,
not in some PC reinterpretation of the words of Hazal. For millenia,
this statement has been universally understood to mean exactly what I
said: that Esav's hatred of Jacom is not the result of anything Jacob
did or any claims Esav has against Jacob, but it is rather Esav's
natural inborn tendency to hate Jacob. If you know differen, please
demonstrate.

Giorgies

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Let the Jews be delivered from their darkness!
    ... an inheritance from their grandfather Esav. ... I disparage his & your interpretation of it. ... So what is *your* interpretation of this dictum of Hazal. ... that Esav's hatred of Jacom is not the result of anything Jacob ...
    (soc.culture.jewish.moderated)
  • Re: Library bug or my fault?
    ... bit-patterns that don't represent integers and so for which your ... integer interpretation is meaningless. ... jacob at jacob point remcomp point fr ...
    (comp.lang.c)
  • Re: Let the Jews be delivered from their darkness!
    ... So what is *your* interpretation of this dictum of Hazal. ... Please base your interpretation on sources actually found in Hazal, ... not in some PC reinterpretation of the words of Hazal. ... that Esav's hatred of Jacom is not the result of anything Jacob ...
    (soc.culture.jewish.moderated)