Re: Is white sugar treif?
yacovachi@xxxxxxx writes:
> kepipesiom@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
>
>> We do not even have to go to the nothein ta'am test. Bone char is
>> active charcoal made by burning bones to destruction leaving nearly
>> pure carbon in the form of fine charcoal. As I was taught very many
>> years ago, such thoroughly combusted substances are never treif,
>> regardless of their origin. If this is correct, then even were the
>> sugar to have some taste of charcoal in it, it would still be kosher.
>
> That's true. I did not realize what "bone char" was.
>
> Same basis for R. Ovadia Yosef, and Rabbi Isaac Abadi, allowing any
> type of gelatin. They maintain the chemical change is sufficient to
> remove the bones form the status of bones. Regardless of their source.
When you say; "They maintain", it sounds to me like their _opinion_.
Could others hold a valid _different_ "opinion"?
Moshe Schorr
It is a tremendous Mitzvah to always be happy! - Reb Nachman of Breslov
The home and family are the center of Judaism, *not* the synagogue.
Disclaimer: Nothing here necessarily reflects the opinion of Hebrew University
.
Relevant Pages
- Re: Is white sugar treif?
... I did not realize what "bone char" was. ... They maintain the chemical change is sufficient to> remove the bones form the status of bones. ... PROBLEM OF GELATIN: ... Even though there is a rabbinic prohibition of eating food that is unfit for human consumption (see: Minchat Cohen Hilchot Taarovot Chelek Aleph 9; Pri Toar 103; Shaagat Aryeh 75; Pri Megadim Shaar ...
(soc.culture.jewish.moderated) - Re: Is white sugar treif?
... I did not realize what "bone char" was. ... >>remove the bones form the status of bones. ... Regardless of their source. ... I usually have a GPG digital signature included as an attachment. ...
(soc.culture.jewish.moderated) - Re: Is white sugar treif?
... I did not realize what "bone char" was. ... > remove the bones form the status of bones. ... Regardless of their source. ... I usually have a GPG digital signature included as an attachment. ...
(soc.culture.jewish.moderated) - Re: Is white sugar treif?
... I did not realize what "bone char" was. ... remove the bones form the status of bones. ... Regardless of their source. ...
(soc.culture.jewish.moderated) - Re: value of relics?
... >> several of the bones found in the sarchophagus. ... My further opinion is that you should do all you can ... relics at Knowth and then turning them into a tourist attraction. ...
(sci.archaeology) |
|
