Iraq and Lebanon



Iraq right now is suprisingly alot like Lebanon during the 1970's.
Sectarian violence tore the country appart, the Lebanese government
just vanished. The Christiani groups thought that they could avoid
sharing power with Shia majority and the the other Islamic groups
within Lebanon. The country was mired in perpetual war until the Syrian
occupation stopped the fighting and the people of Lebanon looked at
themselves as countrymen, not as members of tribes.

I think Iraq is on a similar path. Whether or not it takes 20 or maybe
2 years of secratraian warfare to get the Sunnis, Shias, and Kurds
finally get along and play nice, eventually Iraq will end up like
Lebanon. Just like Lebanon- no ethnic group has the ability to destroy
and dominate the others. The Sunni's can hold Baghdad indefinately (the
insurgency is still not crushed). They don't have an army to crush the
Shia. The Shia have most of the oil, but they would rather have a whole
country- not a third of one. Like the Lebanonese, most Iraqis
ultimately want a whole country (despite 15 years of war, partion was
never seriously considered by any Lebanonese milita).

How long will it take- all depends. Depends on the mentality of the
Sunni, Shia, and Kurds and how skilled the United States is. The new
Iraqi viceroy, Zalmay Khalilzad, seems to be up to the challenge.

http://bismarkian.blogspot.com/

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: The Economist: Lebanon most liberal state in the region
    ... > Well Im stuck inthe country of my tormentors who have harmed me. ... Iranians continue to live harrassement free in these countries. ... Yes, you hate living among Western Christians, you do not want to go back to ... mistakingly believe Lebanon to be an Islamic utopia where wealthy Muslim ...
    (soc.culture.lebanon)
  • Nassrallah press conference
    ... 1- The strength of Lebanon relies on its resistance and unity: ... 2- The Lebanese Army and International forces cannot protect Lebanon: ... hijacknig the country in the name of a futile resistance. ... What victory is is when you are forced to accept the UNJ ...
    (soc.culture.lebanon)
  • Re: Siniora in US and outlook
    ... Hariri only ran in office in Lebanon. ... The way it works in Lebanon according to a law that purports to fight illegal wealth, is that the politician declares his/her "wealth" in a sealed envelope. ... I would have used Barney, the President's Scottish Terrier, as an example but Barney or the Bush dentist isn't the prime minister of a country neighboring Syria that is giving Bush so much grief in Iraq. ...
    (soc.culture.lebanon)
  • Re: Nassrallah press conference
    ... instead of attacking Israel they would have had more land. ... It doesn't matter what country. ... 2- The Lebanese Army and International forces cannot protect Lebanon: ... What victory is is when you are forced to accept the UNJ ...
    (soc.culture.lebanon)
  • Re: Nassrallah press conference
    ... It doesn't matter what country. ... 2- The Lebanese Army and International forces cannot protect Lebanon: ... What victory is is when you are forced to accept the UNJ ... destroying our dignity and bringing up shame to our name. ...
    (soc.culture.lebanon)