Re: Proof?

On Sep 12, 4:18 pm, donie <donien...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
--snip--

Wisdom here is how you critically read and comprehend the ancient
materials withdrawing conclusions from them that will augment living
harmoniously together in today's world.  Intellectually stimulating
discussions would involve qualifying whatever statement you post. You
started labeling the translation of al Qurtubi, but you referred to QS
33:50 & 52. Then you jump to 'deception' in the translation without
bothering to present alternative translations?  I thought you were
bothered by "He , he , he ....he" stuff?


If that is your understanding of wisdom then you are in big
problem. You again shot yourself in your foot , as you only
took a phrase from a complete verse and start to draw your
conclusion from the phrase. How can it qualify as intellectually
stimulating as interpolation is part of your argument which
departed from fact based?

Like I said , I want you to do your homework with regards
to the translation. You brought it up , the very least is to
get the proper translation. For the part of the deception
you should know the verse in relation to the point that was
brought up.


This was my reply when you made an issue of "the translation is
ours".

"Sam you don't need to lough or take pity. As far as I am and this
thread are concerned all you need is to focus on proving that your so-
called great prophet worthy to be called prophet at all, let alone
being prophesied in the Bible. If you were focus you would have seen
that the translation was from an early moslem commentator, Al Qurtubi,
nothing to do with QS 33:52. I present this to scratch you to
comfortably present what you consider the prophetic quality of
Muhammat. Or you can just depart from the al Qurtubi list?"

Sam, let me remind you again statements alone don't count.

Then have you not been making statements all along. Your
claims of '..if khatijah was alive...' etc are statements. You then
based your arguments on such statements. Where are you
going with such 'statements'? You have again contradicted
yourself. Deal with the facts in hand.

sam1528
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Proof? - 2
    ... If the prophet was eyeing zinab: ... (albeit you discussed based on that devilish translation) ... Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, ... This is jesus own words, ...
    (soc.culture.indonesia)
  • Re: Apakah Ada Orang Yg Begini Kejam?
    ... unbelievers after they were Muslims. ... were left in the Harra (i.e. rocky land in Medina). ... A Translation of Ibn Ishaq's Sirat ... Western scholars who "privately" view the Prophet ...
    (soc.culture.indonesia)
  • Re: Proof? - 2
    ... If the prophet was eyeing zinab: ... (albeit you discussed based on that devilish translation) ... No Sam, If you still have some brain cells not contaminated by this ... In a way I facilitate questioning your ...
    (soc.culture.indonesia)
  • Re: Proof?
    ... started labeling the translation of al Qurtubi, ... "Sam you don't need to lough or take pity. ... called great prophet worthy to be called prophet at all, ...
    (soc.culture.indonesia)
  • Re: Smokey with an Hairdryer
    ... It's now 7 mins later and he has not given any other pearls of wisdom ... with or without translation. ...
    (uk.radio.amateur)
Loading