Re: information about "Karen"


htinaungmoe@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
> It is very simple Amanda.
>
> I am not and can not compare Aancient Isrel and current Burma.

You were the one who started comparison between Israeli tribes and
others (all others). I wasn't asking you to make compare that kind of
comparison. Beside that kind of comparison cannot be done as there is
no information EAXCTLY who (which tribe or grop) really lived in the
region what is Burma now except that there were some peopel who lived
in that region and they were referred to s Autralo-Negroid (after human
started branching out of Africa) and that they (most if not all) moved
onto what is Australia and that's what Aborigines descended from. The
same with other regions of the world. No specific information of about
in other region for that time frame. Mesopotamia is considered the
cradle of civilization may be partly because so much info was available
about that region, including the tribe of Abraham, the ancestor of the
Arabs and Jews.

There was no need to downplay the importance of the history of that
part of the world.


> Yes, they wrote their history long long ago, it is very good.
They didn't write the history. They were merely recording as all
developed civilization have done more or less.

>
> I am showing you the tribes current Burma just to show you that, it is
> very difficult and almost impossible to differenciate and count and
> record tribes.
That may be the case with the tribes of Burma. With the tribes of
Israel, they were descended from he same KNOWN root and more
information is available about them.

>In ancient Israel or today Burma, these tribes are all
> humand, not different species, the blood lines are very similar, their
> language/culture are very similar and come from the same family.

I didn't say only ancient Israelis tribes were human.

Hebrews were an organized group unlike the Arabs, and they had their
act together that even after the exodus, and being scattered all over
Europe and Asia, their identity remained intact. Some people see it as
arrogance and refusal to assimiliate to the region to the point of
giving up one's idenity. I, for one, admire them. Why should they give
up their highly developed identity and adopt identity of culturally
inferior groups?

>
> What I am saying is, it is very hard to differenciate and count how
> many Kayin tribes are there in Burma. For Chins as well, there are many
> tribes, but actually the difference these tribbes are not real.
It is not difficult to count the main tribes of them.

>
> Finally who belong to what tribe is hade by human. It is biolobical
> science, it is social thing.

Biological science is science; social similarity developed within
groups that existed in proximity to each other. Usually, people with
same or similar biological background lived in proximity to each other.
Hence their bio info and social group went hand in hand but the social
indentity was secondary.

>
> I am not talking about history. I am talking about tribes. It does not
> matter, it is thousand of years ago or today,
It matters. Those who do not learn from history are bound to repeat
mistakes. The problem with the world has been forgetting history and
history repeats itself.

> the difference between the tribes are artifical. It is not real.
It is not artificial. And it is real.

>
> So it does not matter howerever one count the Isrelei tribes or Kayin
> tribes or Chins tribes, it is both right and wrong.

It does not matter in the sense of who is superior or who is inferior
but it matters for human history to find as much info as possible.

>
> Most of all I have nothing to talk about those Isrelei tribes, they
> have nothing to do with the topic. We are talking about how to get some
> Kayin children out of Burma to Norway.

But he also asked about the Karen and some scholars are considering
karen as one of the lost tribes. My mere menitoning of that triggered
you to attempt to dismiss the notion of Israelis tribes as an
insignificant topics and I am telling you that it is no insignificant.


>I don't know how you survive in
> your life. I have to work, and I have a family. I can't simply afford
> to let the tread wondering with no real subject to discuss.

No real subject to discuss or you are just not interested in *this
subject* (about the significance of Israeli tribes) after you poked
into it?

>
> I am laready late to my work and I have an assignment due on Tuesday.
> So, please let me go.

No one is keeping you but if you want to leave by convincing me that
the Israeli tribes were just any tribe, that's not going to happen.




>
> Whad did you meant by "they are not just any tribes". They claim
> themselves as god's chosen people not like their neighbouring tribes.
> Exceptt from that, they are just human like us, just middle-eastern
> like Arabs, and just Isralei. So no tribe is more special than other.
>
> By reading your post, you become very volatile and irrational. Please
> take care. Have a job and get a boyfriend. If you already have those,
> godd on you please. Don't take offence, I recommended you those,
> because it is good for you. It can be very lonely outthere some time.
>
> Thanks
> As for me I will give you a rest. From now on, I will not reply
> whatever you say on this ng. It is good for you.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: The origin of the word "Burma", Mynamar and the origin of the people Burman/Myanmar
    ... ancient Brahmi language that Sanscript itself originated from. ... In the case of tribes like Karen ... does that make current day Burmese ... The kings of Burma, except Aluangpaya Dynasty were largely of Indian ...
    (soc.culture.burma)
  • Re: information about "Karen"
    ... I am not and can not compare Aancient Isrel and current Burma. ... Yes, they wrote their history long long ago, it is very good. ... I am showing you the tribes current Burma just to show you that, ... it is very hard to differenciate and count how ...
    (soc.culture.burma)
  • Re: information about "Karen"
    ... obviously has no clue about the lost tribes of ancient Israel. ... > We can't even sure of how to count the tribes of Burma today. ... > expect anyone to count the tribes of Israel thousands of years ago. ... > So Amanda, yes it is 10 lost tribes not 12, yes, I am cool with it. ...
    (soc.culture.burma)
  • Re: information about "Karen"
    ... How many tribes does Burma have today? ... We can't even sure of how to count the tribes of Burma today. ... someone come up and say that s/he know exactly how many tribes Israel ... So Amanda, yes it is 10 lost tribes not 12, yes, I am cool with it. ...
    (soc.culture.burma)
  • Re: More Global Warming Woes 1 : NBC
    ... However, for most tribes, most of the time, inter-tribal, and international, ... war was an ever present part of life. ... casual reading of history shows this just isn't true. ... anymore than did rustic people in Europe. ...
    (rec.music.artists.springsteen)