Re: schools banning homework

Right on the tail of that article....
--------------------------------------------
Higher grades, lower scores
Debra J. Saunders
San Francisco Chronicle
Sunday, March 4, 2007

AFTER ALL those years of educators focusing on improving the basics in
public schools, how is it possible that the National Assessment for
Educational Progress just gave America's high school seniors their
lowest score for reading since 1992?

Students in elementary school have improved their skills in reading,
writing and math, but the improvement "stops in middle school and
completely stops in high school," answered Jim Lanich, president of
California Business for Educational Excellence in Sacramento and a
member of the National Assessment Governing Board, who called me from
a NAGB meeting in Nashville.

The new NAEP report found that the percentage of high school seniors
who read at or above basic levels decreased from 80 percent in 1992 to
73 percent in 2005. A mere 23 percent of seniors were rated as
proficient in math, even though students were allowed to use
calculators for one-third of the test.

More bad news: Despite an all-out effort from the federal and state
governments, the achievement gap between white and minority students
remains essentially unchanged. President Bush challenged the "soft
bigotry of low expectations." Many educators say they now expect more
from all students, but they are not delivering.

Grade inflation could be a culprit here. Another report released last
month, the Nation's Report Card on high school graduates, found that
seniors' overall grade point averages for 2005 had risen one-third of
a letter grade since 1990. Also, high school graduates reported that
they were taking more rigorous courses -- but if the courses were more
rigorous, their reading and math skills should have improved.

Sacramento County Superintendent of Schools Dave Gordon, who is also a
NAGB member, sees a "rigor gap" and an achievement gap. The NAEP
report found students who ostensibly are taking calculus, but "are not
even at the top of proficient range" in the NAEP math tests. African
Americans in calculus classes often score below proficient.

And you can't say the problem is that the NAEP test underrates
students -- not when universities are admitting top students, only to
find that they're not prepared for college course work. Last year, the
California State University System found that fewer than half of its
freshmen were proficient in both math and English -- with about one-
third of freshmen forced to take remedial courses.

Lanich believes that schools should evaluate students entering middle
and high school to get a firm handle on where individual students need
to improve -- "and not just expect them to be absorbed and taught
without any adjustments being made to their particular needs."

In California, the high school exit exam -- which members of the class
of 2006 had to pass in order to graduate -- should push up the number
of graduates who perform at or above basic levels. (Note that the NAEP
report was a national test conducted in 2005.)

At last, the focus is on individual student achievement. The exit exam
is not my idea of challenging -- to graduate from high school,
students have to answer 55 percent of eighth-grade level math
questions and 60 percent of 10th-grade level English language arts
correctly. But the test, at least, has forced some students to learn
skills they will need as adults.

About 300,000 (out of close to 440,000) high school freshmen from the
class of 2006 passed the exit exam on their first try. Another 100,000
students had to take the English or math or both portions as many as
six times until they passed. Because state schools chief Jack
O'Connell fought off legal challenges to keep a passing score on the
exit exam from being a graduation requirement, those students know
they earned their diplomas.

For a writer, the saddest statistic is the decline in student scores
for "reading for literary experience" -- from 290 (out of 500) in 1992
to 279 in 2005. "I don't find that surprising, considering the things
that young people are bombarded with," Gordon noted. "It's tough to
get kids interested in reading."

He's right. Kids are so wired today -- to television, the Internet and
videogames -- it's amazing that they have an attention span at all.
But that doesn't mean the schools can give up on them. As Lanich put
it, "Kids don't have a shelf life and they need help today."
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Business Week article on the Rise of Math
    ... You need a few people who can create tools so that many (engineers) can use tools to effect. ... I get a sense that you were trying to teach practical math to associate ... Unfortunately, for many students, those two years weren't particularly ... semesters of calculus and differential equations taught high school math as ...
    (sci.research.careers)
  • Re: schools banning homework
    ... Besides that jazz about the kids being "wired" to the internet, I was thinking back to some comments made in the past about the kids growing up in the early half of the 1900s. ... Educational Progress just gave America's high school seniors their ... Students in elementary school have improved their skills in reading, ... proficient in math, even though students were allowed to use ...
    (sci.research.careers)
  • Re: Is there really that big of a change in high school geometry teaching in the past 15 years?
    ... I came across my 1974-75 high school advanced math notes. ... and an introduction to calculus. ... students who wound up attending college _and_ taking at least ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: Prolems in Mathematics Education
    ... depth in non-honors courses, BUT: ... teachers and motivated students that it is possible to learn ... some rigorous mathematics in high school -- even in non-honors ... math scores above 700, with over half getting a perfect ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: [Off topic] Gay marriage
    ... 11,671 students from the 1988-1994 National Educational Longitudinal ... "Student Mobility and the Increased Risk of High School Dropout" ... American Journal of Education. ...
    (comp.lang.lisp)