Re: Sherman tank engines

On Oct 10, 9:30 pm, Dan <dnada...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Ray O'Hara wrote:
"Dan" <dnada...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:PDVOi.44$KS3.35@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Frogwatch wrote:
On Oct 9, 6:19 pm, "TMOliver" <tmoliverjr...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
"Frogwatch" <dboh...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message

news:1191963559.463848.173770@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

I have a friend who rebuilt a Stearman bi-plane. When I first saw it,
there was no resemblance to an airplane, just twisted framing. When
he finished a couple years later, it was stunning. He told me that
the engine was his biggest problem because it didnt have one when he
got the wreck. He showed me two engines he bought for it (one to
rebuild and one for parts) and told me that these aircooled engines
had been used on a tank, maybe a Sherman. Is this possible? He had
to have a new driveshaft made for the direct prop drive.
Various models and marks of the Sherman came with a variety of power
plants,
all the way from coupled Cadillac's to Wright Whirlwinds radial air
cooled
a/c engines to diesels.

The "reliability" issue for Shermans in Soviet service is in legend if
not
truth related to MTBF transmission mileage, quite significant in a
force not
extensively equipped with ARVs and service troops with shop facilities.

TMO
I'd just assumed most tanks were diesel. Were Shermans death traps
when hit?

The only nation to use diesels in WWII were the Soviets.
Most tanks were death traps; the Shermans were the only tanks to come up
with a solution - wet storage of ammo.

The Sherman was designed, as were most early war tanks, as PART of a
coordinated force of specialty vehicles. Field experience (lacking in
US) dictated an all-purpose vehicle, which the Sherman became when it
was upgunned. The US failed to field a heavy tank to complement it
until too late, though the Pershing and the Super Pershing were quite
good, if too late.

Dan

yeah 3 of them saw action

Super Pershings (90L70 gun), maybe only 1, and maybe it never saw actual
action.

Pershings with the standard 90mm gun saw some action; certainly more
than 3 did so.

Dan

All very interesting, I learned stuff I didnt even know I didnt know.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Sherman tank engines
    ... He showed me two engines he bought for it (one to ... Various models and marks of the Sherman came with a variety of power plants, ... Most tanks were death traps; the Shermans were the only tanks to come up with a solution - wet storage of ammo. ... The US failed to field a heavy tank to complement it until too late, though the Pershing and the Super Pershing were quite good, if too late. ...
    (sci.military.naval)
  • Re: Sherman tank engines
    ... He showed me two engines he bought for it (one to ... Various models and marks of the Sherman came with a variety of power ... I'd just assumed most tanks were diesel. ... though the Pershing and the Super Pershing were quite ...
    (sci.military.naval)
  • Re: Sherman tank engines
    ... He showed me two engines he bought for it (one to ... Various models and marks of the Sherman came with a variety of power ... I'd just assumed most tanks were diesel. ... though the Pershing and the Super Pershing were quite ...
    (sci.military.naval)
  • Re: Sherman tank engines
    ... the wright whirlwind. ... Like other aero engines used in tanks the Whirlwind used on the Sherman ...
    (sci.military.naval)
  • Re: U S - T 34 Tank ?
    ... You have been making a claim that the Sherman was "grossly inferior" ... > I haven't seen your statistics tabulating Panther losses by ... other than that I was going from combat reports by German ... airpower was ineffective at knocking out tanks, ...
    (soc.history.war.world-war-ii)