Re: Bush nominates white house crony to Supreme Court


"Vince Brannigan" <news@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:AeadnT1phMBw49_eRVn-vQ@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> Mark Test wrote:
>> "Vince Brannigan" <news@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
>> news:b62dneahIYlUrNzeRVn-tQ@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
>>
>>>Bush has nominated Harriet Miers his personal friend and White House
>>>Crony to the Supreme Court. She has no repeat no judicial experinece
>>>whatever.
>>>
>>
>> My prior post was in error, Justice Goldberg (nominated by Kennedy), had
>> no
>> judicial experience.
>>
>> Again, your point? It's not required, and many on the "left" don't expect
>> a
>> Justice to be a judge.
>>
>> Mark
>>
>>
> Virtually all the non judicial appointments to the court had distinguished
> records of public writing or advocacy

Vkince, why did you suddenly drop your disbelief that Reid came out in
support of the lady? Are you a bit embarrassed that you found yourself at
odds with your party leadership, who have from what I have seen thus far at
least said that Ms. Miers deserves a fair hearing and that prejudgement
(like what you have been engaging in) is not appropriate? And why have you
rather abruptly discontinued your discourse in the tilt-rotor thread--aren't
you gonna respond to Guy's points, or do they make you uncomfortable (just
as your laughable position that the USAF only wants the CV-22 for the CSAR
role later made you "uncomfortable", so to speak?)? H'mmmm...is this what
you teach your students? When you get something wrong, or the other guy
presents a more cogent argument, just ignore it, run away, and declare
victory? Sad...

>
> Arthur Goldberg was Editor in Chief of the Northwestern University's
> Illinois law review at the age of 19. He assisted Dean Wigmore in the
> Third edition of his treatise. He ahd a long record of public writing and
> litigation.

Yeah, it is really sad for folks like you that Ms. Miers actually
*practiced* law in the real world and did not confine her "experience" (term
used very loosely) to rambling about the hallowed halls of academia in
perpetuity, huh?

Brooks

>
>
> Vince
>
>


.

Quantcast