Re: Population SD or sample SD with many replicates?


"Peter Frank" <peter_frankde@xxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1144858178.299230.264760@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Hi,

The standard deviation is supposed to be calculated with N-1 for
samples and N for the population.

However, in analytical chemistry the population is practically always
indefinite because there is an indefinite number of possible
measurements. So, to be exact the standard deviation would always have
to be calculated with N-1.

Nonetheless, on http://science.widener.edu/svb/stats/descript.html I
read that the population standard deviation can be calculated for large
sample sets (usually more than 20 measurements). Is it an alright
practice to use the population SD formula for measurements with many
replicates or do you always use the sample SD formula?

Regards,
Peter


I would say, if the sample SD is different from the population SD, then you
should use the sample SD--since this is what you measured. If it is not
different, what difference does it make?


--

Dr. Dickie
Skepticult member in good standing #394-00596-438
Poking kooks with a pointy stick
Repeal the 17th amendment; let's reinstate the proper checks and balances
and end mob rule in my lifetime!


.

Relevant Pages

  • Population SD or sample SD with many replicates?
    ... indefinite because there is an indefinite number of possible ... to be exact the standard deviation would always have ... to be calculated with N-1. ... practice to use the population SD formula for measurements with many ...
    (sci.chem.analytical)
  • Re: Population SD or sample SD with many replicates?
    ... indefinite because there is an indefinite number of possible ... to be exact the standard deviation would always have ... to be calculated with N-1. ... sample sets (usually more than 20 measurements). ...
    (sci.chem.analytical)
  • Population SD when sample size > 20?
    ... the population is indefinite because there is ... standard deviation would always have to be calculated with N-1. ... sample sets (usually more than 20 measurements). ...
    (sci.stat.edu)
  • Re: Demonstration that least squares give maximum likelihood
    ... Call the measurements m, m, ..., m. ... mean m and standard deviation sigma. ... It is generally accepted in our field that you can usually assume normality, partly because the errors have multiple causes. ... Another responder alluded to concerns that - outliers apart - there are suspicions that the tips of the tails of real analytical data distributions are bigger and longer than the tails of the normal distribution. ...
    (sci.stat.edu)
  • Re: compare 2 samples
    ... The mean is c/N and the standard deviation is c/sqrt. ... I suspect that in your data, the preponderance of the measurements ... are close to zero, with a very few being moderate or large. ... I'll never know unless I rework the logging code to dump out the raw ...
    (sci.stat.math)