Re: Best DV capture format: MPG vs. AVI




"DW" <davidwess@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:0a33575e-d939-4376-ac98-94c0af246c86@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

I am looking to transfer hidef video from my Sony HDR.HC3 camcorder to
my computer, for archival and further editing. I will eventually burn
blu-ray, export for web presentations, etc. Which format should I
capture (MPG, AVI, etc) to maintain the best qualify for my further
edit projects?

For example, I tried Cyberlink Power Producer (which came with my blu-
ray recorder) but it seems to capture only in mpg format. I tried
Windows Movie Maker, which uses a different format. Ideally, I would
like to simply transfer the bits from my camcorder to my computer with
nothing added or subtracted, and do any further processing on my
computer.

Could someone give me some general advice as to which format to use,
and possibly even which software I should use to transfer my videos
from my camcorder to my computer (running Windows 7 Ultimate)? Thanks.

?????
To do what you want, always transfer in the camcorder's native format
and edit and archive that (on hard drive*S* - and also on tape[s] with
HDV) without transcoding, if practical (24 Mbps AVCHD may require
transcoding to another file type to make editing practical, but by definition,
that involves losses). Since your camera shoots in HDV format (.m2t files,
a type of MPEG-2), stay with that. The easiest way to capture it is to
hook your camcorder to the computer using FireWire and using a great
free program called HDVSplit to download and split the footage into
individual scene files, ready for importing into your editing software. It can
be downloaded at --
http://strony.aster.pl/paviko/hdvsplit.htm
I did not need a driver for the camera, nor did I download the viewer (the
camcorder's viewfinder serves for this). Close down all other programs
while importing/exporting footage. BTW, for viewing the footage on your
computer, you may need to change the ".m2t" ending to ".mpg" - BUT,
be sure to change the file endings back afterward! Um, for more on editing
programs, go here --
http://www.donferrario.com/ruether/hdv-editing.htm
and here --
http://www.donferrario.com/ruether/Sony-editing.htm (Sony makes an
excellent cheap editing program for HDV, Vegas Movie Studio Platinum 9,
but Movie Maker should work for simple editing.)
--DR


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Analog Video to DVD Overall Process/Questions?
    ... What USB capture device did you go with, and what format ... Just a quick note on capture devices. ... It used to be very hard to capture video, it's now trivial and my guess is ... but it appears that mpeg is very bad for editing. ...
    (rec.video)
  • Re: Question on editing mpgs with Premiere 6.5
    ... Adobe Elements 3.0 will handle MPG. ... and editing with premiere 6.5. ... The quality of the mpgs that I capture is fine.. ...
    (rec.video.desktop)
  • Re: Office 2007 UI : customise, revert to 2003, anything....
    ... trying to find and remember where the commands I use most frequently are now ... monstrosity that is the Ribbon. ... I'm now finding that I'm "grouping" my editing needs, ... If I want to format ...
    (microsoft.public.office.misc)
  • Re: When do you lose Resolution?
    ... for all saves while you are editing. ... No other format will retain ALL ... if you want to use JPG as your viewing format--which is ... Also, editing software typically has a default compression for JPG files, ...
    (rec.photo.digital)
  • Re: Standard definition or HD
    ... make low resolution proxy files to use while editing. ... The quality remains the same, so once you're finished, you can ... export straight away to delivery format. ... for you to edit AVCHD. ...
    (rec.video.desktop)