Issue with deflicker, deinterlacing of film capture in Virtualdub



I find that applying a deflicker filter - in this case the MSU
deflicker - to a file of captured film causes an undesirable flickery
"contrail" effect in the image similar to the "tail" setting you can
elect for the mouse cursor in Windows (though why anyone would want
their cursor to look like that escapes me). This is visible whether the
file is processed for output to tape or as a DVD. If it has any
bearing, the file is DV.

Through experimentation, I find that checking the deinterlace option in
the white balance filter and further NOT choosing "interlaced" in the
resize filter, this artifact goes away.

The same footage when using the same filters except for the deflicker
filter doesn't exhibit this artifact.

Why is this? Is there a better way to eliminate it? My concern is I
don't want to degrade the fundamental image quality. I was under the
impression that the reason for interlacing is because a TV scans 2
different fields to yield a complete image. Does deinterlacing reduce
the image quality? The deinterlaced footage looks okay from what I can
tell, it's certainly more watchable without the contrail artifact. But
is the "right" way to eliminate it?

Thanks for all input.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: My Canon 50mm 1.4 USM is wobbling
    ... I am quite surprised the moving part feels very loose and wobbly when ... taking on/off the front cap or putting on a filter. ... Image quality seems to be ok though. ...
    (rec.photo.digital)
  • Re: Thoughts on "Multicoated" lens filters
    ... deterioration in image quality when using a good quality filter. ... Can you disprove it? ... taking more of a beating - and it makes sense as more lens surface is ...
    (rec.photo.digital.slr-systems)
  • Re: Thoughts on "Multicoated" lens filters
    ... On a wide angle lens, I can't normally see any image quality difference ... which case results are much better with no filter at all. ...
    (rec.photo.digital.slr-systems)
  • Re: Thoughts on "Multicoated" lens filters
    ... On a wide angle lens, I can't normally see any image quality difference between the filters. ... If flare/ghosting is a problem with the uncoated one, it's only reduced by using the multicoated one - not eliminated, in which case results are much better with no filter at all. ... I was very surprised to see that when I changed to using the MC filter, image quality was much better. ... For now, I leave the uncoated filter on my wide angle lens, but remove it when ghosting is a potential problem. ...
    (rec.photo.digital.slr-systems)
  • Re: My Canon 50mm 1.4 USM is wobbling
    ... I am quite surprised the moving part feels very loose and wobbly when ... taking on/off the front cap or putting on a filter. ... Image quality seems to be ok though. ...
    (rec.photo.digital)